it depends on the occassion, i would say...both of them look nice!!

I think Hayden is trying to hard... not to look too young for her boyfriend.

i agree, gaellemj! hayden needs to loosen up a bit!

LOVE Hayden!

They both wore it well.

They both look nice but I prefer Nicky's laid-back look.

I agree that Hayden needs to dress her age. It's not necessary to dress like a little tart, but she's a teenager, not a 35 year-old woman. She should loosen up a bit.

I actually really like both. I think Nicky makes it look a lot more casual and young, while Hayden rocks a much more mature look. Winners on both accounts!

I think Hayden wore it better, but shouldn't she have been wearing Old Navy. Nicky looks nice too.

I kind of like them both.

I think Hayden's look wins, but I would wear it like Nicky.

Nicky!
I'm so tired of Hayden's 35-year old looks, she always looks the same -Always those skirts :

it depends on the occasion... i like both

I like them both - Haydens a BIT more! But I love love love that top

kind of off topic, but does anyone else HATE old navy? god their clothes are crap

I think it looks *perfect* the way Hayden wore it! She has such cute style...I love it!

Hayden. I wouldn't have even thought to wear it like that, but she looks lovely.

Beautiful top - I like how Hayden wore it better. It looks lovely tucked into her shapely pencil skirt. Very flattering on her.

i agree they both look good, but hayden's look is a litte fresher, nicky's looks a little more older.

btw, that shirt would make a pretty cute dress if it was a little longer...

I think it looks good on both, although that picture of Nicky isn't her best.

Nicky looks like a potato sack with legs. Hayden wore it in a really classic way with the pencil skirt.

I like the way Hayden wore it, But I don't know if it's just me, but lately she looks like a little girl dressed in her mommy's clothes. I think she tries to dress too grown-up and doesn't really pull it off, not for me anyway.

hayden alwyas looks great let's face it. i love her in this.

I think they both wore it well, but I really hate those shoes Nikki Hilton has on.

I like the pencil skirt with the blouse.

i think hadyen's skirt is too tight. makes her look kinda chubby. she would look really cute if it wasn't for that.

pixi-i also hate old navy. their clothes are ugly and cheap-feeling. and their commercials are so annoying!

Hayden is wearing way too much make-up, but I love the way shes wearing the shirt.

Pixi-I used to work at Old Navy in high school. And yes, for the most part thier clothes are crap. I cant wear any of their pants. Occasionaly I'll find a cute sweater or bag,but thats about it.

Hayden for sure. I am not digging her bright red lips though. She should have gone with a pink gloss.

although the top looks better the way hayden wears it, she just shouldnt be wearing it...shes 18, wtf?/

Both are cute, depending on what the event is...I think I like Hayden's a little more though. I love how ladylike it looks.

I like Hayden's look more in this case. It's too nice of a top for such a sloppy pairing like Nicky's

While I agree Hayden is trying too hard, she does look nicer in this top than Nicky. Much more put together.

I agree that Hayden needs to dress her age... she's 18, not 38.

They both look good. Hayden;s outfit is fine...but yeah, she is dressing waaay too sophisticated. I can see that look on Kate Walsh's character in Private Practice, and she is a doctor in her 30's!

Hayden of crse looks better. The top is given a shapely twist here...it's so sickening to see this trapeze or babydoll tunic top worn like there's no shape underneath. This trend must die.

I can't choose! They both look great.

Hayden looks much better:)

nicky hilton is so ugly. :[