Some serous heavy hitters showed up at one of the most anticipated events of fashion week: the "A Night to Benefit Raising Malawi and UNICEF" hosted by Madonna and Gucci. There's no doubt philanthropy and fashion mix. Katie Holmes chose to wear a sleek dramatically folded red dress while Gwyneth opted for a big bowed pink mini dress. Which Gucci wins?!

Blue Wax
Forte Forte
Ra-Re
Katie most def!
1gwyneth paltrow is also pregnant?
2Yeah I didn't realize that Gwen was pregnant too?
3Katie! I hate Gwyneth's dress.
4I don't think she's pregnant... But while I love Katie Holmes's dress better - damn, Gwyneth has amazing legs!
5WAIT A SEC - Gwyneth is pregnant??
6Yeah, didn't see the news that Gwen was pregnant...
7Gwyneth was, is, and always will be a style icon. Unlike that brainwashed Katie Holme-ly.
8Gwyneth looks so fabulous! I love that dress!
9Katie
10katie's is hot. gwenyth's is just ridiculous
11Gwyneth! Love the dress, love the legs, love her
12Katie!
13Katie... that dress is so slimming on her.
14I thought the other Gwen was preggers. They both are?
15I la-la-love Paltrow in pink....BUT Katie simply looks stunning in that red dress after losing all her baby fat. There is something to be said for going vegetarian after giving birth!
16I'm not sure I'm digging either dress, but I DO dig the two of them side-by-side. They look like archetypes of good and evil. Or like the Barbie versions of good and evil. heehee
17I would have voted for Gwyneth, but her dress is too short and those shoes are terrible! Are those ace bandages wrapped around her high heels?
18That big bow would drive me crazy so I voted for Katie. She looks very elegant and tall! There have been no rumors about Gwyneth being pregnant. Gwen Stefani is and she was also at this event. Fab, I think you made a mistake.
19I voted for Katie, I loved Gwyneth's until you get to the shoes...they are not working for me with that outfit.
20that shade of pink is just not flattering on Gwyneth...or maybe it's just the lighting in the photo, either way there is just no excuse for those hideous shoes...are the 90's back already girls?
21katie...but i'm not so sure about her shoes....
22Sorry gals, I take it back. Gwyneth is NOT preggers
xo.
23Although it pains me to do it, I picked Katie. Gwyneth looks fab in the dress, but the bow overwhelms her delicate face just a bit, and I really, really dislike the shoes with the dress. I do LOVE that shade of pink, though, and she looks fab in it.
I don't think Katie's look is perfect, either... she always manages to look just a little matronly. It complements her shape nicely, though, and the clutch and shoes keep it from making her look frumpy.
24Katie's dress is fierce for sure! Gwyneth's dress is cute, but not like WOW. They both could have picked better shoes.
25Burn the shoes and I'll vote for Gwyneth.
26I think Gwyneth's dress would have been better if it was a bit longer and she had on better shoes.
Katies is really becoming a fashion icon. She looks stunning in the red dress!
27If it wasn't for those shoes, I might've voted for Gwyneth. As is, Katie won.
28Katie.
wtfbow on the other one.
29Definitely Gwyneth! Her dress is girly at the same time simple and it shows her killer legs!
30snore...gwyneth. so over her.
31I luv katie's shoes!
32Neither. Both dresses are hideous.
33i love the shoes Katie has on!
34katie definitely looks fierce
35Go Katie!!!
36Katie is the winner...this girl is the American fashion icon in Hollywood in our generation. I love how classy and non slutty Katie is. And she seems sweet and nice to everyone. Not sure about Gwen and many actresses.
37that red, with those shoes! it just looks so amazing.
38KATIE BABY!!!!!
I can never think of mixing red with gold shoes but she totally works it!!!!
39Katie has become interesting...
40Paltrow but her shoes blew it- so Katie wins.
41Katie : the dress, don't really like it
42BUT red dress+ gold fantastic shoes = very very nice mix!
katie looks fab!
43Gwen's dress is orrible. And she is ridiculous with it..maybe a four years old girl could be lovely with it..not a woman of course.
44Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.