i love the dress but i don't know if it's great on her

its too old for her...

WOW! I did not expect something so elegant from Hannah Montana!

Gelta, my thoughts exactly. Love the dress, don't love it on her

Please, Miley Cyrus, for the love of God, dress your age, which is only 15! She looks good in the dress, the styling is nicely done as well, but it's much, much too old for her.

Of course, this is better than her Grammy fiasco. http://fabsugar.com/1032654

nice dress..simple.

I really like it

I love her dress.

i like the deres.... i just dont like her

I hate it but I know it is because I do not like her. She is so smug in my opinion. Atleast in these pictures she is smiling. Usually she always tries to look like she has this big lip pout or something. UGGGHHHHHH!!!!!

I still can't stand her...granted its better than the grammys...but I still can't stand her.

I like the dress...

Love the dress, but on her it looks blah. It needs someone with a bit of curves to fill it out.

I love the dress, but I absolutely do not like it on her. She is entirely too young for it. Ugh.

She looks fantastic. It's too old her her but it works this time. I love her hair, very sophisticated.

the age she is and the age shes trying to be don't match up

Very cute dress, but I agree with the others, she looks like she's in her twenties here.

I think the dress is very flattering.

The dress very age appropriate compared to what she could be wearing, there's nothing showing that shouldn't be showing so it's all good. Plus, no thick black eyeliner!!! YAY!!!

Gorgeous dress.. I would love to have it myself
But I agree with most of the other posters.. it is entirely too old for her.

i'm undecided on this dress, it's nice but maybe a little too old for her?? I'm glad she's not dressed in something that's too revealing though since she's still kind of young

I am not a fan. I just dislike Miley all together. She needs to act more her age!

The dress is great just not on her.

Age-appropriate and elegant, congrats!

it's a nice dress but it ages her too much.

I love the dress!

oh my, what a positive change!

pretty dress but she's too young to carry it well

great dress, she's a bit young for it, but it looks good

I think she is dressed appropriately for her age. It's a modest neckline. Her makeup and hair are simple. She looks lovely.

She looks good; I don't think it's age inappropriate. Showing too much skin would be inappropriate.

As always, she looks older.

the dress is beautiful but i don't really like the girl in it. something about the poses she was making drove me nuts.

I think that Miley Cyrus is a very great role model. (I love her!) But I think that being a young star in Hollywood has forced her style to become more sophisticated for her. I personally love the dress but I think that she is getting closer to being age appropriate but I think that a little younger looking dresses would be nice.

she looks great...this is very appropriate, I love it!

lovely gown, but i agree that it would be more appropriate on someone who's old enough to vote.

I thinks it's very appropriate. I dont think dressing age appropriate for the Oscars means the same thing for a 15 year old. Of course she needs to look more sophisticated, it's a sophisticated event. It's not MTV for crying out loud. She looks lovely.

i like the dress and i admit to watch her show sometimes when there is nothing on tv. she its funny but i think no matter what you do to her she still would look like somebody smash her face with a plate.lmao

I love the dress. It's classy and doesn't show too much. But her makeup needs to STOP! It's way too much and she looks like she's 30.

What is she doing in the Oscars???

Miley's all grown up!

beautiful, what do people want her to wear, bows and pigtails

a) why the hell is she at the oscars?
b) boring

The dress is nice, but it doesn't suit her.

the dress is beautiful.

why was she at the oscars?? the dress was nice but she looked way older then her age..pass.

too old for her, hate the jewelry with the dress, and the hair.

Much to my surprise, this was my second favourite dress of the evening and I was even more surprised that she was wearing it.

This dress I love it I think it's simple and fabulous.
However I think she is too small for it and not the body appropriate.
This would look perfect on Penelope Cruz.

Gorgeous! I'm not usually a fan of hers however this look was stunning. I disagree with the people that say this is too old for her; she'll be 16 and isn't better to dress chic than to dress too young? I think this looks is perfect and very chic for her age.