Looks like best supporting actress nominee Saoirse Ronan is channeling Keira's emerald Atonement dress for the Oscars red carpet with her own green Alberta Ferretti number. Does it measure up?

Vote on all my Oscars Red Carpet polls here!
Looks like best supporting actress nominee Saoirse Ronan is channeling Keira's emerald Atonement dress for the Oscars red carpet with her own green Alberta Ferretti number. Does it measure up?

Vote on all my Oscars Red Carpet polls here!
That dress is beautiful.
1The dress is beautiful, but the hair not so much.
Um... who is this anyways?
2sorry I don't really like it
3At least she looks her age MILEY CYRUS.
She was in Atonement and she'll be in The Lovely Bones.
4I dunno.. She sorta looks like an elf to me. I don't like the dress.
5Gorgeous color, nice dress.. Too bad the hair and make up is kinda plain.
6This dress really works on her. I don't think anyone else could pull it off. She looks ethereal.
7I like dress for her, but she needs a new hairstyle!
8age-appropriate and great for an age-appropriate look!
9Yes, with a fancy dress like that there could be more done with hair and makeup. However, she is a teenager. Look at how gorgeous her skin is!
10i like the dress, age appropriate. i don't mind the hair because she's young she shouldnt do too much
11that child needs to eat a couple of cheeseburgers, she looks so frail. the dress ages her as well.
12not loving it.
13i dont like it!
14The dress is totally age appropriate for her. ALTHOUGH it looks like she had it fitted without wearing heels so now the length is off
15really pretty color, but the hem looks weird...the length looks wrong and the embellishments at the bottom look wrong. she needs to do something about that hair. It's too slicked back. She should have let it down with curls.
16i like it, its very simple and pretty, though i wish the hem were longer
17I agree I wish the hem was longer, but I think the dress looks pretty on her. Her hair and makeup, that is another story....
18I love the dress, but her hair is to tight
19i'm undecided. while i love the color, the hemline irks me.
20cute =D
21She looks age appropriate. I like it.
22I agree Jessness i thought the same thing about the length. Her hair needs to be out too, to soften the look.
23She needs her bob back!
24I think we need a fourth choice: Meh. That's how I feel about this dress. It's not great but I don't hate it. It's just meh.
25I like it; and it's appropriate for her age.
26I like color of her dress
27loved her in atonement and she looked perfect for her age tonight as well
28Too nightgown...too flat and plain with the hair. It's pretty, but not fancy enough for the Oscars.
29I think people need to remember that she is only 13 so she is new to this whole thing but I do think she picked out a pretty dress that is age appropriate. I just think she has some technical issues that a good tailor would have caught (like that hemline)
30the dress is okay but i had no idea who she was until i read the comments. she's 13? she looks a LOT younger that miley cyrus.
31I think she looks age appropriate but the dress looks like it doesn't fit.
32Beautiful dress!!
33Hates it. Not happy with the hem.
34That's really pretty and great for her age, I can imagine 13 is tricky for the red carpet looks, you could easily go too young and cute or too old and trampy.
And I'm glad she kept her hair and make-up simple for the same reason. I think she got it spot on, but she's an Irish girl so maybe I'm biased
35i didn't like it
36The length of the dress ruins the whole look for her
37I like it, but he hair is a little too severe.
38the color goes well with her eyes- i'll forgive the mis-steps on hem and hair cause she is only 13- i think she looks fresh and pretty
39I loved that dress on Saoirse but they should've done something different for her hair.
40The hair ruins it for me. The dress is nice, and like everyone else said, age appropriate, but that hair..
41Very pretty girl though, and yeah i think she looks thin, but my own almost ten year old is thin and tall, and I feed her constantly. I think it's the age and genetics
I like the color...
42PUT ON SOME WEIGHT PLEASE.
43i'm not quite sure how i feel about this one. i think that the color is great for her and the style is very age appropriate - i just think that maybe she should have left her hair down....
44i think she looks lovely! she's a kid, i can't believe people would really dissect her look so much. i think it's very different to analyze an adult's style, but i remember how i felt when i was 13 - totally self-conscious about everything. i think a reasonable adult can shrug off opinions, but kids are a bit more sensitive. i think it would hurt if people were talking about my hair and my makeup and my hem. then again, i wasn't even allowed to wear makeup when i was 13.
45I like the color on her and at least she looks her age, unlike other teenage stars, but she could have let her hair down and a longer hem-line couldn't hurt.
46Stand up straight girl!
47I agree with ajah ... I mean this is a 13 year old kid, she's probably in the 7th or 8th grade. no need to pick her apart. she looks cute, the green brings out her eyes.
48The color has nothing to do with Keira Knightley's one. However, except there's something strange with the length, I think she made a good choice, very appropriate for her age. She dares something less simple than something like Ellen Page's style but it does the job.
49No.
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.