I LOVE her......and I love the dress, but I think she looks best in colors, but shes beautiful nonetheless!

Wow, wayyyy too much makeup

i think it's boring

she is by far one of the top five most beautiful performers out now. just amazing.

She looks perfect....couldn't get any more beautiful!

PERFECT! she is the best look out of the entire group! absolutley elegant and gorgeous!

I think she looks very pretty... and I love her dress!!!

BUT, every time I see her I can't get over how different she looks... (I know, I need to get over it)

she's beautiful but something about there's something about this dress i don't like. she sort of looks like she's at prom or in a beauty pageant

i like the dress- I wouldn't have thought that she would have chosen this one... but it's cute. makeup is slightly overdone but still looks cute

She looks good, better than the majority.

She's beautiful, stunning.

Color, great. Cut great. Carrie? CUTE! She looks so happy and glowing!

One of the best of the night, which is really saying something given how hard that shade of silver is to pull off.

while im still anti metallic, i think this dress is beautiful and it looks great on her
flutter-the one, the only, accept no substitutions

I think the dress would look much nicer in person, but the shine looks really cheap in the photos. She looks very pretty and nice, but kind of safe and boring.

Love the dress...love the hair...gorgeous!

She looks stunning as usual, but seriously Carrie, don't lose any more weight!!

love it! nice color... and nice hair

i think she looks totally beautiful all around. but something about her looks plastic-y. it's hard to put my finger on what exactly i mean by that word too. i don't know, maybe it's just that every time i see her at these things she just seems a little too perfect, a little too sculpted, like someone built or constructed her. never saw that much of her season on idol, but what i saw she does look pretty different. eh, i'm done rambling. she's very pretty regardless.

Very enchanting. A bit more color wouldve been nice.

Very beautiful.

Bit Barbie-like but somehow I really like they way she looks here

She's cute, she just always looks too done up.

This was the prettiest dress last night.

she shoulda wore this dress in black. the silver makes her skin tone look dull.

I think she always looks pretty but there's something about that I don't like. I don't know. As if she's probably b*tchy away from the cameras. I could be wrong.

Anyways, yes, she looks very pretty.

Love her and the dress!

I voted love it because I thought at least it fit pretty well compared to some of the others.

Love it. Love her hair, too.

Probably my favorite of the night... I know it's safe and boring but she looks gorgeous!

ugh, flawless...

i don't really know who she is, being from england, but she looks lovely, if a little boring.