We all loved this BCBG dress on Ashlee back in September when she broke it out for the MTV Video Music Awards. Between the body conscious fit, voluminous hem, and paneled bodice, there's a lot to admire. Apparently, race car driver Danica Patrick didn't think it was too shabby either — she wore it for an appearance on the Late Show With David Letterman yesterday. Both ladies have knockout figures and pull it off with the greatest of ease, but those girly peach satin heels Danica chose might be a little too girly for such an edgy, sexy piece. This one's on you — who do you think wore it better?


















Ghibli
Katia Lombardo
Red Herring
Danica's looks more fitted for her than Ashlee's. But I think that it is more Ashlee's style. Danica just looks weird in dresses in my opinion.
1A dress like that would be so hard to pull off as feminine, and for me Danica Patrick failed on that. My vote goes to Ashley because her look is edgy, which for me is what the dress is meant for. Plus, her look is so together. The satin shoes and the dress just don't match.
2I have to go with Ashlee on this one.
3I dont like Ahslee's style, but the dress is better on her. I don't like the dress (I see it tacky and unflattening) and it makes Danica fat (poor girl, she isn't but seems to be)
4I think they both look nice.
5I think the dress is very unflattering and neither look good in it.
6Def. Ashlee. Danica has is pretty but the dress doesn't look right on her.
7While this difficult to wear dress better suits Ashlee's style, I would not say Danica looks fat in it! She looks a tiny bit fuller than Ashlee, but Ashlee is also about six inches taller than Danica and Danica is facing the camera straight on. But still... fat? No.
8They look pretty much the same. Ashlee looks a little better because of the angle...but for the record, Danica is way, way cooler.
9as much as i hate to say it- ashlee. it does make danica look large- and she's not a large person. but she has broader shoulders and such and this just doesn't flatter it
10Ashlee. The dress does not suit Danica's body.
11Ashlee's dress just seemed to really fit well...
12Danica should have done something a little more sophisticated with her hair. I think that would have helped her look more like a woman in her own right instead of putting someone else's dress on and trying to pull it off.
13ahhh i want that dress!
14I don't like it on either of them...hate the dress.
15I want this dress!!! where can I get it?!?!
16Ashlee rocked that dress.
17I have to vote for Mary Louise Parker - she's sporting the same dress on the May cover of Paper magazine, and, well I just like her better than these two (in any outifit).
18Definitely Ashlee. Though I love Danica's shoes
19I think the dress is too young-looking for Danica.
20Ashlee.
21Wow, I never thought I'd vote for Ashlee Simpson for anything good. But the dress looks much better on her--Danica looks awkward.
22I love the dress!
23The dress makes Danica look wider than she really is. It's tragic because she has a really petite body.
24Ashlee
25i fell in love with this dress when i saw it on ashlee so my vote goes to her
26i fell in love with this dress when i saw it on ashlee so my vote goes to her
27"Danica's looks more fitted for her than Ashlee's. But I think that it is more Ashlee's style. Danica just looks weird in dresses in my opinion." LOL so true.
Subsequently I’m listening to Ashlee Simpson - Rule Beaker as we speak. I think her style is great!
28I picked both, but now I'm leaning more towards Ashlee.
They both have INCREDIBLE legs though!
29I picked both. Both have great legs but they look super dark compared to their arms and face.
30Ashlee looks so good here! That dress is gorgeous on her.
31It looks way better on Ashleeeee. It's not flattering on Danica at all, which is sad because I think she's the prettier of the two.
32i chose ashlee. but, i personally think the dress would have looked nicer without that puffy bottom layer. if it were longer and sans puffy layer it would've looked way better.
33i dont like ashlee at all but the dress does look very good on her, and the back shoes go better with it.
34i think the dress looks trashy, so neither.
35Definitely Ashlee.
36Hi,
37ANYONE KNOW WHERE I CAN GET THIS DRESS?????
THANKS
Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.