Mirror, mirror, on the wall. Who's the fairest of them all? You all loved SJP in this fabulous Nina Ricci creation at the movie premiere last night, but what are your thoughts on Lindsay Lohan wearing the same gown in a photoshoot for Harper's Bazaar? SJP kept her look glam accessorizing with a matching cuff and layered chains while Lindsay opted to pair the frock with a casual, fitted leather jacket. They both look like fairy-tale princesses but who wore it better?
7trends
Jovovich-Hawk
Forte Forte
Sorry LL I luv ya but I think SJP pulled this one off betetr!
1SJP of course!
2Lohan's jacket looks tacky. SJP is looking fab as ever... she does Ms. Bradshaw proud! I love that dress!
3SJP of course!
4I would NEVER choose Lindsay over SJP...
5Lindsay cheepens the dress - you can see through it, her boobs are at her chin, etc. Sarah Jessica looks like a goddess.
6I love sjp, but there is something about the way linds rocked it...
7Its hard to pick.
Its an awesome dress and would prob look good on anyone, and they're both in such different settings, a photo shoot and a red carpet, so I just picked Lohan cause I like her better
8sjp definetly
haha that kind of rhymes
9sjp all the way
10SJP
11SJP. Lindsay is a skank.
12SJP all the way. For some reason Lindsay just cheapens the look of the dress. SJP makes it look elegant.
13I want that dress!!
14I like LL better! The dress doesn't look right on SJP and isn't really suited for the red carpet.
15The stunning SJP!
16I like both looks.
17Yup, lindsay looks cheap, sjp looks like class!!
18SJP wore this much better!
on a side note I do like Lindsay's hair here.
19no contest--sarah jessica all the way.
20Lindsay's jacket totally ruins the line. It's cute and fun, but it covers up the waistline. SJP has the perfect elongated hourglass figure to do justice to the dress.
21Do you even have to ask Fab? We like SJP
22I do not like that dress, is too pretencious and is not elegant..it seems too much a plastic wrap ( like domo pack ) so the leather jaket hit it on the nail..it let become it more artstic, more avant gard. I prefere lindsay way.
23Why would you cover up that gorgeous dress with a leather jacket?
24I don't care for it at all either way.
25SJP
26This is like comparing apples to poop.
27Anything Lohan is thumbs down for me.
28SJP looks elegant and poised in the dress while LL looks as if she's playing "dress-up". SJP has a dancer's posture and grace and body, while LL looks like girl in a costume. One is wearing the dress and the other -- The dress is wearing her.
29LOL chellybean
30SJP of course! Lindsey makes even the most expensive couture look cheap like her.
31is this even a question?
32SJP, by a landslide. It's not bad on LiLo, but it looks much better on Sarah Jessica.
33Who in their right mind wears leather (aside from shoes) with a dress like this.
34linds isn't even in the same stratosphere (wardrobe wise) as sjp!
35i like linds
36for the first time in a long time, I think that LiLo looks midly presentably attractive.
37Lohan's jacket hits right before the widest part of her body, thus hiding the cinched-in waist. Makes her look 15 pounds heavier and HIDES THE DRESS! I love this dress, the silhouette is incredible and should not be hidden.
38SJP all the way....
39SJP! I feel the leather jacket was suuch a mistake; its casual look absolutely ruins the feel of a beautiful gown!
40I think it's interesting that they can both wear it and both look age appropriate in it. LL kinda Priscilla Presly and SJP looking tres elegante. SJP wins tho!!!
41SJP did but the dress is horrific
42I'd never thought I'd pick Lindsay over Sarah...the metallic princess type gown just looks more age appropriate on Lindsay and the leather jacket really works with dress.
43SJP looks fab!
44I like them both.
45lilo's looking prettier but i dont like tough jackets on dresses. it looks lame
46can't stand either of them, but Lindsay all the way - I love the hair and leather jacket to punk it up a bit - I love the pic!
47lindsay
48It's hard to choose.
SJP looks like a stardust on the runway; while Lindsay looks like a glammed rock star.
49Easy...Miss Carrie Bradshaw.
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.