The different style compliments both of them.

I rarely see a white shoe I like, and I don't like these.

Leighton! Her heels are FAB and she's gorgeous!

Leihgton's dress is cuter. Even though everyone can see you be-hind.

I like Leighton's better but I think its too short even for her so I picked the other even though I dislike Howard Stern immensely.

it looked good on leighton!

I like them both, since they're different, and they both seem to suit the wearers.

Based solely on the outfits, Leighton's is superior.

Leighton is so gorgeous!

Leightons, but I don't like that clutch. I dislike the cut of the other dress and the white shoes are funky (in a bad way).

I chose Beth's almost solely based on the length. Leighton has great style, but she is wearing a tunic top, not a dress--way too short!!

i agree with silly3. so sick of white shoes.

Hmmm.. I picked neither. Leighton's is tooo short and I can't stand the white shoes.

Leighton is always amazing!

I don't think this is a good comparison for a "who wore it better." You could have just picked any two random dresses to compare...

As much as I love Leighton's style...I just like the dress Beth has on better...

Leighton is prettier, but I think Beth made the dress look classier and fun without being too constricting

Hate the white shoes!!!

I think it looks cuter on Leighton...and her shoes are fabulous!

Leighton rocked it better!

For some reason, the white shoes make that outfit look vulgar and common.

I like both, but Leighton pulls the outfit together much better, and makes it look very chic. Beth's looks to casual and doesn't work well.

Beth! Sexy maturity over slutty -ish.

I think the dresses are very different and they both wore them appropriately. Leighton has the whole super-structured and a little avant garde thing going on, so the weird angular clutch makes sense, and black shoes are appropriate for an event. I think she's making a statement on the red carpet.

Then Beth's dress has a more relaxed shape, so I like that she wore her hair down and had more casual accessories and shoes (to me, anyway, white shoes read more casual than black).

Did I just totally over-analyze that?

That's why we're here, spharrell!

Leighton pulls it off

I chose Leighton even these dresses shouldn't even be compared as the same

Leighton's dress is wayyyy better - although it looks crazily short - and that clutch is beyond fab, but I do like Beth's shoes better...

i like leighton's shoes better but i like beth's dress better- but they both look nice

How the HELL do you sit down in a dress like that? when you sit, the behind of a dress automatically goes up a bit. Your entire ass would be bare once you sit down.

Leighton! Not only do I adore the girl, but I don't actually like the other dress at all.

Leighton. Beth's is an uglier version of the dress, the color blocking doesn't look good at all and the length is too matronly.

Leighton, without a doubt!Just Stunning!
xoxo

Leighton!!

Leighton!!! definitely

Leighton

i don't like the dress on leighton. it's just too short. and what's with the clutch by the way? i dont like it.