I Love Lucy.

I think they both look great.

They both look good in it.

Both look good. I wish Lucy were standing to see the fit on her.

lucy does it better.

It is not the same dress as you have stated.

The only similarities are the colour and the designer.

The sleeves are different the, cut is different, the material is different.

And how can you compare someone standing up to someone sitting down and you can not even see the whole of the dress ?!?!?!?!

Victoria for sure!!!!!

I like the shoes Victoria has on, but Lucy made the dress look flirty.

Lucy looks fabulous.

Don't care for a sleeveless yellow dress with closed-toe black pumps.

Much cuter with Lucy's sandals.

Victoria wore it fine, I mean I like the whole 60's touch....but the truth is Lucy's way was more creative and imaginative without working against the dress itself.

So, I voted Lucy.

is it just me or do i think that the same dress looks totally different when worn on 2 different people

Lucy looks too prim, I think--I like the flair VB gives it.

Lucy.

My home girl Lucy Liu forever!!

I would have voted both if that were an option.

Definitly Lucy

Lucy. She's curvier which makes the dress look better on her IMO.

Victoria. Im not feeling Lucy's nude pumps

Definetely Victoria. She always looks amazing and polished

lucy all the way

I voted other because while I think Posh looks thebest in the dress I love Lucy Liu so much that I just can't vote against her besides she looks lovely and fresh too. OK so I am voting for Lucy now

They both look good and chose the style that suits them better; however, I voted for Lucy because I (in agreement with lizzylu49) don't really like closed toe black pumps with such a summery dress.

Victoria; even though I would change the shoes, she looks very put-together.

Victoria!

you can't even see half of lucys dress!

VBecks.

Definitely Lucy liu. I prefer the way her outfit is accesorized and the fact it it isn't so tight. Also, I think that pale yellow works better on Lucy's skin than Victoria's.

I agree with JK Boogie, this is not the same dress. The lapels on VB´s dress are much smaller and Lucy´s dress has a much looser skirt. But they are still both nice!

lucy!!

I choose other because I really like they way they put their own stamp on it. Lucy's style is more in line with my taste, but Victoria looks very... Posh.

They both look great, but I think Lucy's skin tone works better with the dress.

I like everything about both looks (even VB's shoes), but Lucy's shoes are just fabulous and I love how her look is effortless - plus I'm like crazy obsessed with her and her gorgoeus, adorable freckled face...