While I think Jenny is much more beautiful, I do think Heidi looked stunning in that dress. I think it was the red clutch, the white shoes and the hair that did it for me.

I think the dress looks great on both of them, but I hate Heidi's shoes and purse with the dress. I think she should have let the dress shine.

Heidi did not do the funky thing correctly. That clutch and those shoes are SO WRONG. Jenny looks Awesome!

I dunno...as much as I hate to admit it, I think Heidi's look better.

I'm so over herve.

Doesn't the term "well-endowed" imply that it was given by their maker...

just saying...

I don't really like how Heidi accesorized the dress, but she looks more stunning in it.

i hate to say this but heidi looks great!

heidi for sure.... im a sucker for pops of color and that clutch is STUNNING!

Heidi looks gorgeous, but I don't know how I feel about wearing platform heels to a beach party. It wasn't really occasion-appropriate. I voted Jenny.

Firstly, I hate these Herve dresses...horizontal stripes + skintight = baffling to me. Regarding the vote, I am so, so torn. I remember seeing this picture of Jenny and thinking that she looked great. Now I see Heidi (it doesn't even look like her) and I think that the dress may actually look better on her figure (cosmetically enhanced though it may be), but I hate the shoes and watch (I am OK with the bag). I think that I may hate the shoes so much (and the fact that it's Heidi) that I pick Jenny...but I am still conflicted that I even gave pause!

Why can't Heidi stop wearing copy cat clothing. If she isn't wearing the same outfit to seperate events she's wearing something else somebody else already wore better. I just wish this girl and her demon lover would disappear

I hate to say it, but Heidi!

Ugh, it pains me to even say this, but I prefer it on Heidi. She looks amazing.

Jenny because she actually wore the dress better--I dislike Heidi's choice of accessories (the white heels are bad and the watch even worse). Both of them have the physique to pull off the dress but Heidi's looks better.

I realy hate heidi,and her accessories are not so good,but she wears it reeeeeally better.

Definitely Heidi. She looks really pretty, although she could've ditched those clunky shoes.

I'm surprised people are still saying "I can't believe I'm saying this, but..." because we all know the reason why we all dislike Heidi is because she's still dating that d**chebag Spencer. I think if she ditched him, she would be on her way up.

Heidi looks decent for once.

I love the look on both, but I think I'm going to have to say Heidi. I really like her hair up and wavy. At first glance I thought she was Kristin Cavallari! I guess that means Heidi's learning how to dress better...

WHAT HEIDI!!! Jenny looks confident and absolutely FABULOUS!!! That dress deserves to be shown off with the exuberant certainty apparent in Jenny's eyes. Heidi looks as though she needs affirmation that she FINALLY looks good, too. So, both, really, but, Jenny more so.

OMG, white platform pumps? No, never.

I like her clutch, but not with that outfit. What is with the white Timex IronMan or whatever she is wearing? Who the hell styles Heidi? She always looks just off mark.

I vote "neither."

def. Jenny

Jenny...because who knew I would ever say this but here goes... Jenny looks more classy then Heidi..who manages to make every outfit look cheap and mall like...

Ok *phew* saying Jenny looks classy isn't really as hard as I thought..now that i think about it..as of late she has looked a lot more classy (ever since dating Jim Carrey I think)

i totally just saw this dress in a window at south coast plaza today. how bizarre.

they actually suit the dress really well, but jenny completes it with a better fitting heel.

JENNY ALL THE WAY SHE FILLS OUT THE DRESS AND EVEN THOUGH IT IS RATHER HIDEOUS SHE MAKES IT LOOK GOOD

General Heidi discrimination aside. I think they both look really good.

Heidi b/c Jenny looks sort of naked.

I like Jenny's shoes better.

I also have to say that Spencer is not the reason that I hate Heidi. HEIDI is the reason that I hate Heidi. Such a manipulative cat. Spencer is only further evidence of her idiotic, famewhorish ways.

Heidi cheapens EVERYTHING.

I know I will probably get bashed for this, but I think the dress makes Jenny look a little thick through the thighs and belly area. Heidi's figure looks way sleeker, and much more narrow, so I think physically Heidi looks better. However, I hate the accessories that Heidi chose, so Jenny is styled better.

i hate to say it.. but heidi looks better

I said Jenny because first and foremost, Heidi looked ridiculous for a beach party and white platforms are a no, no matter what. Especially on someone who likes to overdo it with the tanning like her.

And no, she wouldn't be any better of a person if she dumped Spencer. Watch the first season of the Hills, before he ever appeared. She's a whiny, childish, bratty princess. Heck, she even admits it when she breaks up with her boyfriend.

I hate these Herve Leger dresses. I don't know why they ever came back in style.

Jenny looks a lot better. She kept it simple and let he great bod and the dress do the work! Heidi looks ridiculous with that huge red bag and I don't like the shoes.... and she wore those heels and that dress to a "beach party" - ummm get a clue Heidi!

I don't like Heidi's accessories at all. I think Jenny wins in that department but the dress looks better on Heidi.

THATS HEIDI!? She is only a shadow of her former self.
Anyway, I vote for Jenny strictly on principal – my new rule is to never vote Heidi anything.

Don't like Heidi but love the dress and accessories on her. Props to her stylist.

*hates myself for saying this*
Heidi...

oh my god...i just voted for Heidi. Please God make it the last!

im really NOT a fan of Heidi but i voted for her simply bc she looks better in the dress and nothing more. Its def her accessories that make the look.

that dress is soooooooooooooooooo amazing!!!!!!!!they dont need anything with that dress they both look stunning!!!!!!!!

Heidi's shoes are gross.

Doesn't Heidi look like Sarah Michelle Gellar in that pic??

jenny looks awesome