Rose. The necklace just brings the dress to a whole new level.

The necklace looks as if it was part of the dress.

i agree with the necklace comments. Plus, the length of the dress on amy smart doesn't look that flattering

neither. The dress is hideous

I think they both look really cute, but if Rose could just lose the neck ruffles and steal Amy's giant ring it would be perfect for me.

And did anyone else think Amy had a sea urchin on her wrist? I had to do a double-take.

Both of them are nice. I like the one with the beading on the top better though.

That's a really unflattering silhouette.

the dress is nasty, but rose is the lesser nasty.

Rose, Amy looks scary and I thought I'd never say that.

Yakala!!! Neither. That is quite and unflattering dress.

It's all about the necklace!

I really don't like that dress.

the necklace is a nice touch to an otherwise plain dress.

Rose. The necklace was a good move, as was her darker eye makeup.

Rose. There's something about Amy's shoes that are throwing me off.

DEF. the makeup, the necklace, the hair. i love amy but she is on a lower level

Rose looks better. Amy looks like she just kinda threw the outfit together without really thinking about it.

I think the dress is frumpy as hell either way.

I don't know who either of those girls are, but I like the one on the left.

Rose! you know, when I saw this dress on Amy, I though that it was absolutely hideous. but Rose makes it look pretty and very stylish - that stunning necklace makes the awful neckline look wearable, and her shoes are very sophisticated. I really don't like her makeup though, it makes her look so much less beautiful...

Rose looks so much better, she is a star

Rose! Great styling.

Amy... I am afraid she/her stylist did not quite understand the dress, what a misser.

nither... the dress is aweful !!

Rose. The necklace definitely helps the dress.