I love the look of that rough-cut diamond ring...it's so different.

Such a great clothing line that Kate has. It should be on the catwalk because I can't see anyone in the high street pulling this off, including I!

I have a love affair with jewelry, and I have to admit that I don't like that ring. It's not my taste at all. To me, that diamond looks like a chunk of broken, dirty glass. In my opinion, that cut (and chunks of carbon) does nothing for the diamond.

I want to clarify that I love old-cut (more crude cut) diamonds, like mine-cut, rose-cut diamonds. The charm of older, cruder cuts is not lost on me.

However, this crude-cut has no aesthetic quality. JMHO.

Its so natural. It reminds me of a Crystal. And since my name is Crystal Ive always had a soft spot for them. Absolutely beautiful! However I can see why some people might hate it.

Mine cut and rose cut diamonds are awesome. If I ever get engaged, I want one of those for my ring, forget the super expensive sorts.

The inclusions kind of bug me, too, though. My mom has a 1.25 that she had reset in a pendant...it has TINY inclusions, down in the point of the stone, and they're like the 5 points of a star. That's character. One that looks like it's full of junk, nah.