Many of you adored the Phillip Lim navy ruffle dress Lindsay Price wore recently, and for good reason. The folded, tiered ruffles, the poofy shoulders — they're beyond charming. Apparently, model Liya Kebede loved it as much as we did, because she wore it out on a cold night in NYC. These ladies are wearing the same dress in the most opposite ways. Lindsay is party-ready in red suede Mary Janes and red lips. Liya, not so much. She's bundled to the max with black tights, black boots, and a black coat. Whose look are you digging more — Lindsay's playful version or Liya's moody take?


















DKNY
Lyie Van Rycke
Tripp
Lindsay!!!!
I absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE her whole look. The dress is amazing and the shoes are to-die-for.
1I like both looks. I like the versatility of the dress.
2Lindsay but what is up with her face, looking like Margaret Chow again.
3You can't really see how Liya is wearing it because she has a coat on. But Lindsay looks good in it.
4lindsay
5i really like liya's with the tights and boots; gives the dress a more wintry feel; i think she could stand to lose the jacket though.
6Lindsay Looks so much better,,and i Love her shoes,,
7i like the color of liya's better and how it stands out against hte black tights. i'd just lose the jacket!
8Liya. How much surgery has Lindsay had? I don't like her shoes, either.
9Love Lindsay! She always looks great.
10I voted Lindsay because she pulled off her look a lot better than Liya. liya's outfit looks nicer(IMO), BUT she looks like trash! Slap on some make-up, PLEASE
11I voted Lindsay, but honestly, I wasn't particularly smitten with each of the two. Besides, you should add another celebrity who has already worn this dress: Jennifer Morrison. She wore this 3.1 Phillip Lim dress best at the 3.1 Phillip Lima flagship store opening back in June.
Jennifer Morrison in 3.1 Phillip Lim
12both wore it well imo. i voted for liya b/c i love her lol but they both look really good. you have to remember that liya has a coat on and isn't at an event. it's hard to say who's better
13I love lindsey
14I was gonna go for Lindsey because she looks so cute, but then I realized they were wearing the dress for very different occasions, so I had to call a tie, because if anything Liya's is more practical for everyday!
15Lindsay. I have no idea who Liya is, but seriously, if you're going out in public, put some makeup on. It wouldn't kill you. If you're going to spend that much money on your clothes, why not spend a little more on makeup? Just because you're a model doesn't mean your face is gorgeous without makeup. Anyway, Lindsay looks Fab. The end.
16Who just woke Liya up for this picture? Poor girl looks either half asleep or stoned!
17the dress has an amazing shoulders why to hide them?!
18I think this was a case of the lesser of two evils. I don't like the dress on either girl. The girl on the right bundled up too much and the girl on the left had those red shoes that I'm not too sure about.
19Definitely Lindsay.
20Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.