i love them both. and the burnt sienna hue is gorgeous.

I don't really like either...the strap is too wide for me and they're a little TOO chunky.

I prefer the $$$$ ones.

The BCBG version is such a great alternative!

I like the wedge effect on the Marni sandals

I don't think I like either of the shoes but I love that you came u with a cheaper version that is almost exact - amazing (how do you do that)?

No where near the same for me. One of the main reason the Marni ones are so amazing is because of the wedge.

Oh, just watched those Marni platforms in lookbook, girl and look were fab.! And I'm also likey the cheeper version, good job.)

I agree with some of the previous comments. The wedge is what really makes the shoes amazing, along with the cut, which the BCBGirls pair doesn't quite replicate. The shape of the less expensive ones actually makes them look like they're from Payless, which is scary for the price you'd still be paying for them.

They are both so UGLY

These shoes would draw negative attention to your feet. They look cheaply made and just too heavy. Of course what do I know, I live in Bernardos, Boems, and Mystiques most of the time.

I don't think I like either very much. They are too chunky for my taste.

I don't like either of them

neither are my style, but of the two I actually prefer the BCBG - I like the two colors, and I definitely prefer that heel (I hate wedges)...

i like these an they look really comfortable which is key when you're living in NYC and you walk everywhere

I really love these. And have for awhile. They run very small but are very comfortable. They are from '08 S/S so you might be able to find them; or at least cheaper than the $900+ price tag they were going for when they first came out.