Here's a difficult one for me. I like how Rodriguez' olive skin blends in with her satin Dolce dress and creates an is-she-isn't-she? effect. But those tanlines? No no no! As for Rose, this emerald green satin dress is adorable and complements her pale skin tone, but I'm not so sure about her bright pink lips and gold accessories. Help me decide!


















Masini Gioielli
Boots
Bottega Veneta
I like it better on Rose, the green looks great on her skin
1Rose , love the green , the pink lips are ok in my opinion but yeah me too not sure about the gold accessories
2Neither. I think the satin material on both dresses looks cheap
Of course Michelle's tanline
is definitely not helping....
3Rose does it much better (the dress is a perfect fit and color), plus I don't like Michelle...
4Michelle's.. I love Rose's too, but I choose michelle
5Michelle looks better. I still can't get used to that new Rose face
6Michelle's but yea, the tan lines don't work. lol There was an actress that got married recently and she had tan lines. I can't remember who it was. grrr.
7Michelle. But Rose looks great too.
8Both of them are bautiful,but I voted for Rose. That green is sooooo great colour for her.
9I think that both of them did a good job on their looks! The colors that they chose suited them perfectly.
10GREEN, and the gold accessories seems to work for me. Michelle's dress is a pretty color of gold, BUT that thingy around the mid- section looks like a corset she's wearing over her dress. Like the shoes on BOTH of them.
11i totally hate that rodriguez girl.. but altough i like her dress lenght better,i voted on rose because of the color.
12Both look good, but in this case I prefer Michelle.
13:$
14Michelle looks really classy! Rose looks a little bit trashy in my opinion!
15Both should be an option. Those dresses are gorgeous.
16the green just pops.
17I picked "NEITHER" because I dislike the fit of Rose's. I like Michelle's better however I HATE those tan lines; for me, those lines(more like patches) ruin the look.
18love the green on rose's skin!
19Neither really. The gold is too tight and the tan lines, I agree, NONO. The green is a pretty color but I think I would have liked it better with black or silver shoes. The gold makes it to Christmassy.
20Rose McGowan sort of creeps me out sometimes, but I voted for her anyway because she looks great in that green.
21I think since they are two very different dresses, they both look good.
22Rose looks tired and Michelle needs to glam it up.
23Maybe monochromatic is in, but I'm loving Rose.
24I don't think Michelle's dress does much for her, while Rose's dress really pops and is short and sexy.
25I love the shade of green in Rose's dress.
26I voted for Michelle's dress. Though i'm not a huge fan of her's, I thought she looked very classy and elegant.
27I'm not crazy about either of them, but I prefer how Rose looks and her dress is a bit more appealing.
28omg rose looks scary lol
29the green looks beautiful
30I love Rose's dress..so I voted for her even though her face looks weird!
31i dont know but i think ill pick the green
32Rose Mcgowan looks absolutely gorgeous in that emerald green. I think that she always looks greeat though. She always turns up in the most incredible gown. Well except the one from her marilyn manson grammy date!!!
33i like michelle. she looks like a golden goddess...... rose.... what the hell happened to her face..... & her dress looks like a bad 80's prom dress
34The green is great on Rose
35i really like rose mcgowan and her pale skin! she looks great!
36michelle looks way better.
37i've been going back and forth on this for the last 5 minutes and i can't make up my mind! i think both ladies are gorgeous and both dress choices are good...
38i like rose better, except i dont like her facial expression. well that has nothing to do with it. but rose.
39michelle rodriguez looks weird.
rose has on a beautiful dress. but the gold does not work. it gives her a christmas-ornament look. you can't get away with combining metallics with this dress. i probably would have worn some peep toe camel suede slingbacks & some ice around my neck. just my opinion though.
and as for michelle. everything looks a mess. it looks like she just came back from vacation.. or hiking the mountains and washing her face in the river... and threw on this dress. i like her shoes though.
40The dress looks great on Rose. Beautiful color.
41i don't really like michelle, but i think she looks better. the gold accessories don't look right with rose's green dress.
42Michelle!
43I'm ot digging the satin at all, both dresses appear ill-fitted.
44this is probably the best we've seen michelle, but those tans lines, yikes!
45Rose, absolutely.
46Rose, I just don't like Michelle or find her attractive.
47This was hard hard, I thought they both look amazing really. Anyway It's nice to see Michelle with a softer edge. I love it.
48michelle's tan lines are tacky & rose's plastic surgery is tackier.
49Rose looks super hot!
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.