I think they both look great!

I like January in it better. But I am so tired of this D&G corset dress. I feel like we've seen it a thousand times.

its a tough choice cause they do both look fab, though marisa edged january out slightly

Marisa is perfection.

Jan & Marisa both look beautiful in the dress - but Marisa looks a lil' better for some reason. It flows on her.

On January it looks classic, clean. On the other one it looks too plain.

I think January accessorized it like it was supposed to be. Her look is very cohesive. But Marissa does look better in it, that dress was made for her body so I had to go with Marisa.

I think marisa wore it better

neither. but it's probably because i don't like the dress. i think Rihanna could actually fill it out quite nicely.

Both of them of course!

I'm not crazy about the dress, but they both look nice in different ways. Oh, Allytta- Rihanna would look amazing in that too! She has a great figure for it.

They both look great, but it looks so natural and easy on Marisa.

marissa wauw what a body

it helps that Marisa is also a Victoria's Secret Angel...

its too hard to pick really, its such a gorgeous, gorgeous dress and they both look sensational.

Marisa knows how to work the dress and I like that her hair is down.

I have to say Marisa, but then again she could rock anything with that body of hers...

I voted Marissa.. she's smoking hot. Also, her big wavey hair complements the dress' simple silhouette.

I think they both look amazing, but since Marissa is a model she knew how to pose to look the best in this picture.

Erm, what? Why is Marisa winning the poll? She's so cheap and tacky!

I KNEW I'd seen this dress somewhere before...they both look okay in it, but honestly, I just don't like it very much.

wow, this is absolutely gorgeous!!

I agree with Lola, Marisa makes the dress look so cheap and tacky. January looks pretty and classy and she accessorized it better.

OK January accessorized it better i think most of us agree with that BUT Marrissa's hair flows backwards following the dresses seam line and unfortunately whoever wheres it with more confidence always wins so hears to you Marrissa

Marisa!

i think they both look good.

yeah this one was a toughy, but marisa has an almost perfect figure for this kind of dress, and she just filled it out that LITTLE bit better.

Both look great!!! But Marisa is bring the sex appeal, so I voted her.

the dress looks like an over-the-top nightgown. blegh...

January, it doesn't really seem like Marisa's style.

I've never really liked Marisa Miller.