Mariah looks like a woman while Victoria's nipples are just scaring me.

Mariah has the curves. Victoria looks like a doll in a too big dress

i LIKE THE COLOR OF VICTORIAS BETTER

victoria for sureee. i think you can see the details of the dress better and i love the shoes she paired it with!

mariah looks like a 40 year old woman whos trying to look younger than she really is... victoria looks just right

Victoria... even though her boobs really annoy me.

love the dress. don't love either of them.

victoria even thoight shes scary i like the color

sorry.... thought

I like them both, but I picked Mariah.

Posh needs a bra and a sandwich. Mariah looks womanly and gorgeous!

Mariah looks gorgeous and super feminine!

I feel like Mariah makes the dress look tacky. I hate how it's see-through

they both look gorgy

i think it looks more sophisticated on posh

Neither of them.

I feel like Mariah would do better in another dress because of her gorgeous curves - Vic. looks good in this dress though b/c of her athletic figure.

Love them Both =D

details of the dress are seen better and i think victoria's fogure flatters the style of the dress more

i think Victoria looks cuter.

Mariah looks better because of her curves.

i like how dainty victoria looks in it (^-^)

I think Mariah would have looked better if her sandals didn't have a stap around her ankle, they're cutting off her leg and making her look stumpy. Victoria looks better, but if Mariah would have worn a different shoe they both would have been equally hot.

i love both, but its nice to see victoria wearing a color other than black. and i agree mariahs been looking great lately.

mariah looks beautiful and curvy...victoria looks way too skinny-and i hate it when you can tell someone isnt wearing a bra.

Mariah. She fills out the dress better. Even though she tends to wear everything way too tight, I think it works here. Daintier shoes would have been a better choice, however.

Mariah. Victoria looks way too matchy-matchy.

oh wear some bra, posh. you aint so broke that you couldnt get one.

I think Cream looks better as colour, makes the design stand out...

Love them both and agree with shini

Victoria looks better...its more elegant and fresh....mariah cheapens the dress some how n looks a bit chunky n squeezed into it.....

Even though Vic's girls are at full attention, you can see through more of Mimi's dress, so I pic Vic

Posh, the dress is cuter in the nude color. But maybe I just think that cause I can't stand Mariah Carey and wish she would go away for good.

Mariah

Victoria looks better i think

Mariah!!! ♥ her curves & her body, she is sexxxy! Victoria is too fake & skinny.

Victoria looks better. Love that colour.

OF COURSE MARIAAAH ! i think this dress was designed 4 maria !! she looks gr8 in .. but victoria ! .. she needs some one to feed her lol !

I love this dress, both ladies look great but my vote goes to Mariah, she looks overall better in it because of her curves.

Mariah's dress is cuter in colour, but Posh looks best in it.

Definitely Posh..

Posh makes the dress look good in an innocent way and Mariah makes the dress look sexy and grown up.

Mariah doesn't seem to realize what size she is

Mariah makes the dress look sexy and Victoria makes the dress look sweet! I can't decide!

I think it looks better on Mariah - Posh's nipples sticking out are not attractive sorry. Although I'll admit I like the nude color as well.

dislike the shoes selected on MC [when paired with this dress]. boo.

Posh looks fab! Her look for this dress is simple yet perfect. Mariah is trying to look younger and it is not working for her.

I like posh's look, Mariah's boobs are too big she looks all stuffed

GOD i LOVE that dress on Victoria. It's so beautiful!

I think they both look good, but Mariah's curves are totally rockin' the dress.