Here we have two ladies in red: Sienna in feathers and Claudia in bows. Although the tight bodice on Sienna's dress flatters her, I prefer Claudia's gown because it's unlike anything I've seen before. Who gets your vote?
Featured
More on FabSugar
Fall Award Season
Top Brands
DAY Birger et Mikkelsen
Clarks
No Romeo
God, this is like having to choose between having your hands chopped off or your feet put in a blender! They both look awful... did Sienna get a three year old to do her make-up with a box of Crayolas or what?? And as for Claudia, even she seems to acknowledge how ridiculous she looks!
1You shouldn't be able to see your belly button when you're wearing a gown.
2wow, sienna looks stunning! claudia, even if she's one of my compatriots, this dress is just EEEWWW!!!!
3I don't like these dresses..
4i dont like either. sienna's has too much feathers on the bottom and claudia's dress should not have the stomach showing. they just don't look good.
5The dress on Claudia Schiffer reminds me of the one in the Seinfeld episode where Elaine buys a dress at Barneys, only to find that it looks horrible in real life, away from the skinny mirrors. That one had the midriff cut outs and everything.
6they both look like cheap wh*res.
7Both dress look ugly to me - sorry ladies!
8Both 80s horrors!
9Sienna! She looks gorgeous
Claudia...not so much 
10Sienna rocks that dress. I don't care for the bows on Claudia.
11Neither of them!
12Hate both of the dresses but Claudia wins buy a fraction - what's with Sienna's eyebrows?
13what's with the feathers and the cutouts? omg!
14ps...whoever styled them needs to be fired!
15Sienna but only the dress itself, her hair/makeup looks wretched.
16Kiki tee, you're too funny. I agree with you they both look awful in them but I bet if I see these dresses walking down the runway I be all like "pretty" but something about what the ladies did to their hair and make up AND EYE BROWS is turning me off.
17I think that's the worst I have ever seen Sienna look, and Claudia looks like a prom nightmare.
18Claudia's makeup is just weird... I guess its better from the two but doesn't mean any are that pretty...hmmm
19Both of those dresses are horrendous
20ive seen someone wearing claudias dress a couple years back..forget who. the bottom of siennas dress is horrid.
21In response to zc: it was Sela Ward. She wore it in the same color too to the Golden Globes a few years ago- good memory!
22I voted Sienna, even though the bottom is awful - I dont like Claudia's at all though!
23Neither.
I'm the same age as Claudia, and I'm sorry, but she's too darn old for that look.
24both are horrible, but I picked Claudia
25They both suck. =P
26I adore that red. Claudia looks like she forgot how to pose.
27neither! the red washes them both out. claudia looks like death warmed up and sienna just looks uncomfortable.
28Ew to both!
29NEITHER!!! HIDEOUS TO BOTH!
30the feathers remind me of a drag queen and the bows in the middle look just...ridiculous!
31Oh dear, Claudia looks weird with the cut-outs. I don't think it would look appropriate on anyone being that she has an amazing body. Sienna, looks lumpy. Forgive me, I love her but that dress does nothing for her.
32they both look horrible! sienna (who i normally find gorgeous!) looks like a mash of michelle williams and madonna in the 80's!
33i don't like how you can see her bellybutton! this isn't the beach!
34Neither. I have disdain for those feathers on Sienna. And the bows and placement make Claudia's torso look super long - like someone added in an extra piece of torso. Stare at it! It's almost an optical illusion! Perhaps she would look nicer if she stood up straight!
35Eeek! Both look horrible.
36Both dresses are hideous. Sienna's face looks bloated and Claudia's make-up makes her look like a walking corpse.
37I really like Sienna's dress, I think looks great on her figure and is a bold statement that works. Claudia's.. my first reaction was ewwww. Her body is fab, but that dress showing her belly button on the red carpet is sooo tacky
38OH MY, OMG! ;| Gross
39I don't like how you can see claudia's skin...
40Claudia's peek-a-boo look is too trashy for this event. Sienna captured elegance, class, and and beauty all in one. Miller for the win!
41DEFINITELY neither! Both dresses are beyond hideous.
42Miller, even though it scares me to say that.
43OMG I'm scared ... they are both horrendous! Haha Sienna's make-up is hysterical!
44both dresses are horrendous
45Neither !!! OMG...this is really bad.
46Aww, I eat my words, neither hideous nor boring - Sienna looks amazing. Claudia on the other hand ...
47EW! Very bad choices on both their parts! Red should be done elegantly, not like that!
48there were so many gorgeous gowns at that event but these are not. great color, tacky designs
49Sienna looks like she put on 15 pounds to me in that dress...
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.