Attention! It's a battle between a French and an American. Frenchie Marion Cotillard first wore Vivienne Westwood's red satin strapless dress to the London of Public Enemies. Ankle-strap platforms and a black Stella McCartney clutch went along for the red-carpet ride. Then 90210's Jessica Stroup showed up to the Vivienne Westwood Spring '10 show in Paris wearing the same dress, only with different accessories. Purple Brian Atwood platforms and diamond jewels were her accompaniments of choice. So, who's it going to be?
Source: Getty
Isotoner
Morgan
Rick Owens
The dress is ill fitting, and it looks poorly made and with really bad, wrinkly fabric. It would look bad on anyone regardless of body type, what shoes and what jewelry is worn with it.
1Its hard to pick. It looks like its falling off Marion and on Jessica its a wrinkled mss.
2Lovely on Marion, messy on Jessica.
3although, i'm not crazy about this droopy dress
4Aw, love Marion but the dress isn't my thing. I like her sheos though.
5Voted Marion, but this dress is unflattering on everyone.
6jessica looks terrible in it, it looks like the dress is wearing her.
7Marion hands down. It's probably the French in her that makes everything she wears look effortless and elegant.
8I like the red and purple too but the dress doesn't fit Jessica as well, and it is very wrinkled looking on her. Marion always looks very at ease on the red carpet. Her confidence helps make her outfits.
9Marion, because she ironed it. Heh.
10The dress itself looks better on Marion; I like Jessica's hair, make-up, and shoes better.
11this dress is horrible.
12I agree it all comes down to fit. Marion's dress is a better fit, and I also like how she's styled better.
Although Jessica's dress is probably wrinkled from sitting.
13Marion, because she styled it better (those shoes!) and she's wearing the dress, not the other way around.
But it doesn't fit well on either of them, really.
14BEAUtiful dress by Miss Westwood, but it doesn't fit Marion and Jessica forgot to send it off to be pressed. Let's do better next time, ladies!
15I must add, also, it takes a LOT of effort to make Vivienne Westwood look bad. Good job girls...
16the dress is pretty; it's just ill-fitting at the top. I prefer how Marion styled it, mainly because I think Jessica's shoes are too edgy and they don't go with the classic glamour of the dress.
17and, grammar Nazi alert (sorry; I can't help it) - I think you meant "London premiere" (you left out a word)...
What a horrible dress... Marion.
18I agree with most of you all. This dress doesn't seem to do much for either of them in my opinion. Love the color though!
19Definitely Marion. Jessica looks like she wore something she rolled into a ball.
20The_thing_is_just_a_total_mess.
21Marion
22Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.