don't like nicoles boots

Nicole boots are definitely weird....neither really wear it well...

I can't get over those totally lean long legs on Audrina! Green with envy!

but what about Audriana's bag/purse? it does not fit at all with the rest of the outfit!

Nicole killer boots

i don't like nicole's boots

I picked Audrina, mostly because her choice of shoes was so much better!

I picked Audrina, mostly because her choice of shoes was so much better!

hate the boots.

I didn't think either one really rocked the dress.

I voted for Audrina...but I'm not a huge fan of the dress to begin with.

Looking at JUST the dress, not the shoes... I think the girl on the right looks better, she fills out the dress better than that other chick. It's sort of a shapeless dress so I think someone who's more curvy looks better in it.

I voted for Audrina just because I adore her and the shoes she has on with the dress.

Are we sure Audrina's dress is not silver...?

i picked audrina but she seriously needs a bra

Audrina; Nicole's boots are not cool at all.

I said Audrina. Don't like Nicole's shoes.

Audrina

The dress looks better on Nicole Scherzinger.

I don't like the boots.

Nicole's boots are FUG with that.

The peep-toe shoes go better with the dress!

Nicole... but they both look like they just came in there nightshirts!

i'm surprised so many people prefer audrina's look. i don't actually know who she is, but i think the dress dwarfs her frame. i don't really like the dress, but i think it fits nicole better, and those boots are fierce.

I love the dress on Nicole... but the shoe killed it for me!!!

I agree with Lorelei Audrina's is silver! And gold shoes with silver dress is an interesting choice.

Ooo it's my girl Nicole...she looks smokin' hot in this dress, I think...but then I get to the boots and EEEK - not liking those at all.

shoe choice by nicole...is just weird, I dunno about audrina's either..

Nicole's boobs are too big for this dress, making it hang higher and look more like a top without pants.

I don't like the dress, so neither looks good.

the boots are totally wrong for the dress, so i went with Audrina

I think NIcole filled it out better, her boots were ugly but...

those booties are heinous... looks like someone bedazzled some really nice boots.

nicole's boots are ugly

I don't like the dress and they need to eat.

i LOVE audrina to death but what she paired with the outfit is just...ehh. and i also love nicole to death, but the boots are a little off. they kinda look cute, but, if you saw the TRL episode where she wore this outfit, she states that she wore them in her new solo video with T.I., whatever you like. therefore, i think it's a shameless way of self-promoting her new solo career.

Agreed with Reema. But, I guess if I had to choose, I'd pick Audrina? *Shudder*

I voted neither, though if I had to pick I'd go with Audrina because her shoes are yummy.

Neither - although Audrina looks much better I watched the Hills Aftershow when she wore the dress and a bra could have really done her some good. She was really floppy in the chest area! Nicole looks a mess in this dress and the boots just top it off!

Neither ! Nicole boots are just a horrible thing and Audrina doesn't look comfortable at all in this dress. at leat her shoes are great.

audrianna, bc nicoles shoes ar hideous

I liked nicole untill I saw her shoes!!!!!so then I choose audrina

They both need to wear a bra!

neither...

I chose Nicole because she filled out THE DRESS better. Her shoes were heinous, but the question was about the DRESS, not the SHOES!

Nicole looks like she forgot to put on her pants or skirt or whatever is supposed to go on the bottom there... seriously, just like she's wearing a long shirt and boots, which are really ugly and don't go with the dress at all. Audrina at least looks like she's wearing a dress! Plus, I love those shoes with it.

Audrina, the dress looks better on Nicole, but, I hate those boots.. The dress isn't that fab either..

I don't like it on either one, but if I had to pick the worse of two bads, I would choose Nicole. She wears the dress better, sure Audrina's shoes work better, but we are talking about the dress. I don't know what possesed Nicole to wear her shoes (ick!)

Audrina.

i think you basically can't wear a trapeze dress like this if you have any sort of thighs (as tan and toned as nicole's are). if you have stick legs like audrina then it doesnt seem like you just forgot to put on pants.