Remember that gorgeous sequined Balenciaga babydoll dress Sienna Miller wore to the premiere of Factory Girl? Well, during my usual morning visit to PopSugar today, I caught Katie Holmes wearing the same dress seven months later! This is a tough call because both ladies are wearing black opaque tights and patent pumps — almost identical. I approve of both. Who gets your vote?
JC de CASTELBAJAC
Decleor
Patrizia Pepe
Sienna!!!!!! I don't find this at all flattering on Katie!!! I just don't think that it's her style!!!
1both of them look very nice in it, they both chose to wear it in very similar ways, but for me Sienna wins maybe it's because of the the hair, don't know
2Neither - I am not into this dress.
3This dress looks like a white trashbag rolled in sequins. Far from loving it.
4I chose Sienna because it is a fancy dress and looks more in place on the red carpet. Don't get me wrong, I think it still looks fab on Kate buuuutttt Sienna chose a better time/event to wear it!
5Sienna. Katie's doesn't fit her well... or something.
6they both would look infinitely better if they stopped slouching and stood up straight.
7Sienna
8Katie looks completely awful in this dress. I would never think that a Balenciaga dress could make someone look so frumpy. Besides, it's not her style at all. Now on Sienna it looks so cute and goes much better with her body type and style.
9Katie's body shape is very odd. This dress requires someone with a petite, boyish frame like Sienna's. For some reason, Katie looks lumpy in this dress. She needs to figure out what flatters her pear-shaped body.
10This is the ugliest dress I have ever seen! I said neither. They probably paid a fortune for it too.
11Sienna - this is too fancy for day wear
12Sienna is crouching!!
13I prefer it on Katie
it makes them both look like they have saggy breasts and bad posture.
14Neither. Both are slouchers and their boobs look like they are hitting their navels.
15Sienna
16the dress is fugly
17Neither I do not like this dress..and I dont like that the dress disappears with their tights into one black blobo.. sorry
18Hideous dress, but between the two, Sienna wears it better.
19I agree with all those above...this dress makes them both look like they have horrible posture..stand up straight!
But, Katie has amazed me again.....she spends hundreds of thousands of dollars on clothes and consistently looks bad. Either its just a mess, unflattering, too old. Please, someone help this woman.
20The dress is ghastly. The black trim on the shoulders and at the bottom is hideous. The cut is funky. Just an odd dress.
21I said neither as well. I just think this dress (though expensive) looks like it belongs on a child.
22That dress is god awful.
23Neither. I don't like that dress.
24Neither. The dress is shapeless and doesn't flatter either woman.
25Sienna's boyish body and blond hair looks better.
26Sienna, better as a event dress.
27katie ruins the dress with her frumpy umkempt hair.
28something looks off about katie's look. maybe it's just the angle the picture is taken at.
29I feel just awful for Katie. She looks like Britney Spears with short brown hair in that dress. The dress makes her look so large.
30Sienna
31The look about the same to me!
32Sienna,the dress lookes better made on her and on kaite Holmes it looks like it has less color and it looks to lose for her, in my opinion Sienna wore it the best.
33Katie... You should at least make an effort to wash your hair if you're going to wear that dress.
34Sienna... Not a fan of hers AT ALL but she wears it much better than Katie.
35I love that dress! They both look fantastic!
36Sienna has a smaller chest which is what these babydoll, high waistline dresses look best on, IMO (although I'm not totally wild about the dress).
37It may be Balenciaga, but it is horrid.
38While I LOVE the color combination of ivory & black, I hate this dress, because it makes one look like they're wearing a backpack!! Ridiculous. Also, it contorts the boobs.
39this dress is wrong no matter who's in it
40they both look like they are wearing backpacks and you can see the straps
41Sienna rocked this dress better than Katie who looks a bit swollen.
42Sienna looks better. Katie looks dumpy in it, and she's not dumpy looking at all in most of her clothes.
43Sienna looks better. Katie looks dumpy in it, and she's not dumpy looking at all in most of her clothes.
44Sienna looks better. Katie looks dumpy in it, and she's not dumpy looking at all in most of her clothes.
45Sienna cause she looks better & I don't like Kate Holmes.
46Not a Sienna fan, but she looks better in it.
47This dress make both of them look fat and breastless... :-S
It might be used with Britney´s brown boots for the worse look of the year!
48Sienna, it flatters her more.
49Sienna looks really dresse3d up, going to a formal event. Katie looks like she is going on "play date" with her child andother mommys.
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.