That maxim list is terrible - of course Maxim is terrible too, so whatev. But, seriously, that was just mean and nasty.

btw I bet that list was written by some fug writer who sits in his room and jerks off to pics of eva and jessica alba all day. What a freak show. Those comments were just terrible!

I don't like the way either of them wore this jacket, althought I like the jacket itself.

Not surprising that Maxim voted her unsexiest (seriously, though, what an awful list) because she's not in your face sexy like Maxim likes. I don't really even think she's all that pretty, but she has great style and seems to be a cool woman.

Carrie always!!!

She isn't the prettest girl but she works what she has. I like her.

Maxium has no idea what they are talking about anyway. Their idea of sexy is women with a fake tan, thick, fake breasted and overly airbrushed on their pages.

Are we chopping wood? I don't like this cardigan AT ALL!

Carie!

they look like lumberjacks... not a hot look.

the maxim list was rude and everyone on that list (except trashy britney, who I frankly agree is f*cking disgusting and deserves to be on such a list) has some serious talent.

sorry but that cardigan is so ugly.

i was furious about the maxim unsexy list. SJP is completely sexy, and is far better than some of the other women on the list (who still thinks britney is sexy?)

well, maxim certainly got the press they wanted from that stupid list!

i like both looks, but wish that LL added another layer under hers.

i'm not a fan of this cardigan
hmmm,... nope

and F*CK maxim!
eh hem

first of all, SJP always wins. second, if i see LiLo wearing sheer leggings one more time i'm going to lose it.

I'm in the minority here. I like it simple and I don't like the heels with it.

SJP!! Lindsay is over. She looks like a 40 year old retired stripper. And Maxim can go to hell! SJP may not be very pretty but she has a charm and class about her that makes her a role model. She never is gossiped about, you won't see her flashing her crotch to cameras, and she's not passed out drunk in clubs! Maybe Maxim should think again about what makes a woman sexy.

I love Maxim, its hilarious. I have to agree with them.

1) SJP- She isnt sexy, she is cute and quirky.
2) Amy Winehouse-Disgusting woman nothing sexy about her at all
3) Sandra Oh- Not sexy, more like 'interesting lookin"
4) Madonna-Yea, she hasnt been sexy since the 80's, purple leotards are pretty much a turn off for any gender
5) Britney- should have been #1

I thought the Maxim list was funny... I don't like the Cardigan

Usually I'm a fan of the "too much is never enough" approach, but this time I'm voting for Lindsay. Her coordinate looks stylish and comfortable. SJP looks like she's trying too many trends at once without considering how they look together, and the bulky piles on top with those socks and stiletto heels make her legs look like matchsticks.

SJP looks way better.

LiLo is wearing leggings and UGGS.....UGH!

sjp is so fug

I don't really pay much attention to Maxium. I didn't even know they had a list.

SJP can STYLE ~ Hands Down!!

Carrie! SJP is the best!

Carrie Ladies it's official that men understand sexy in a very different way that we women do and who cares about Maxim and their list ? I'm sure Sarah Jessica Parker does not so....

How an ugly jacket can turn beautiful women into transexual lumberjacks...

SJP of course,and even if people don't find her sexy it is in bad taste to have a poll of that nature..much like most of the content of Maxim anyway I suppose. And Lala your right, she issued a statment that she didn't care about Maxims opinion of her

Whatever Sarah wears is always glam and chick!!! I love her

SJP!

I say neither coz that coat is fug. I agree that SJP is not sexy though. She's fashionable (or at least she has great stylists) but she's far from sexy.

that maxim list is incredibly rude. i'm shocked SJP got # b/c i remember sometimes watching SATC and- especially in episodes where her hair is natural with great curls- thinking how stunning she looked

btw, there was also a list of UNsexiest men and Dr. McSteamy was one of them...wtf indeed...

Sarah for sure...hands down!!

Seriously, that Maxim list was such crap. SJP is fun, beautiful, smart, and sexy. Maybe it's in a more subtle way than the obvious, but really. Anyway, Pat Field is amazing and I much prefer Carrie's look--Lindsay looks a little lumberjack.

Im not sure who did it best, but I'm leaning towards SJP... Whoever wrote the MAXIM thing is seriously screwed up.. i agree with him on Britney, but the rest of them, I mean Maddona is like the most respect artist in the world... THAT WRITER NEEDS HELP

SJP may not be sexy but she's soo unique to me & she has the most enviable wardrobe!! I just want to raid her costume storage from Sex & The City!! haha Too funny with the Lumberjack comment *LMAO*

Carrie, but I don't really like the jacket though

Carrie, it's a more interesting outfit. Lindsay's looks too 90s revisited for my taste.

Wow. I thought Maxim couldn't get anymore dumber...even dumber than Askmen.com.

SJP may not be the prettiest thing around, but at least she has CLASS! But I guess the editors of Maxim are thinking with their other heads instead..

Well, here's a big %$*! you to Maxim!

Anyway, I voted neither.

Lindsay looks like crap!

Sarah Jessica Parker looks like a horse.