Paris looks like a train wreck in this dress.... well i suppose she always looks like one haha.. but no i say carmen looks way hot! and paris.... not

I love the color of Paris' dress, but Carmen's fits better.

I think the dress looks really bad with hose, Carmen looks way better and I love the green cardigan with the purple dress.

Carmen looks very femine and casual, Love it!

Yea, I agree with javsmav

Carmen! I have that exact dress bookmarked...I love Catherine Malandrino.

I'm so obsessed with purple recently...love that dress.

Carmen!

Carmen, oh la la.

The dress makes paris look washed out.

Neither! But the dress itself is pretty.

Carmen is too matchy with the shoes and Paris....

I love the color of Paris' dress, too. Also, I like how the dress contrasts with her fair skin - pretty and fresh.

The only part I don't like is the dark hosery and shoes. I would have prefered more lighter or neutral colors.

Paris has been wearing hose with everything these days. In some other photos you can see that it's because her legs are banged up (bruised, nicked, scraped, all kinds of stuff) I wonder whats up?

I love the color of Paris' dress.

Paris is walking like she is wearing combat boots and pants. Definitely not her!

Carmen, love the green & purple combo.

I think the cardigan is too casual to look good with the dress. The green is also too dull. I would choose Carmen without the cardigan. Paris looks like a mess.

i don't like how carmen electra looks in this dress, her tan and her boobs just don't do the purple and flower pattern at the hem justice, and that much.
i like paris's color better... but... is she wearing shoes? i can't tell. this is an awful picture of her.
but i just don't really like it on either of them. it doesn't seem to fit their personas.
i do like the dress a lot though

The dark hose of Paris' look really made her lose out on this one. Even though I don't like Carmen's mismatched cardigan it's better than the dark hose. I'm going with Carmen on this one.

I adore the coulour of Paris', but the rest is a bit tackified. I don't like Carmen's style in general, so I'm undecided.

Paris looks like a hooker in that dress! And Carmen looks classy!

Carmen looks much better. I love the color of Paris' dress but I don't think she can pull it off with her coloring, it makes her look too pale.

Paris looks like a line backer....and summery dress+black hose+black shoes=very bad idea

Carmen! Awesome colour!

I love the dress and Carmen's color combo!!! So pretty!!

carmen hands down!

paris is looking a little like courtney love, circa 1993.

Carmen looks awsome in that lovely purple!!! It fits her body like a glove but Paris looks sloppy and cheap! I wonder why...

NEITHER.

I like the color of the dress Paris is wearing, but Carmen looks much better. She a little plastic, but it's most covered up I'm seen her lately.

carmen looks better

Both of them look nice,but i like it on Carmen

I think Carmen has the body for that kind of dress.. And pairing it with a green cardigan makes it even better. Love her!

carmen looks better...now im going to go wash my mouth out with soap

Oh dear. Paris Hilton kinda looks like Courtney Love in that photo.

Carmen looks WAY better than Paris... love that color!

I put neither.

whatever! paris' look rules! carmen electra looks like she has old lady church stockings on or something. i think paris looks really retro and exciting.

Paris has ginormous man feet!

Carmen: too much boob
Paris: not enough boob. haha

oof! neither!

I'd say carmen, though i love both colors

definitely carmen.