Pink and Shakira in the Same Dress at the MTV VMAs

MTV Video Music Awards: Who Wore It Better?

September 13, 2009

Red carpet fashion faux pas alert. Pink and Shakira just arrived on the MTV VMA red carpet in the same Balmain dress! Looks like they were able to laugh it off, however. Who wore it better?

Vote on all of my MTV VMAs polls here!

Source: WireImage

43 Comments

3 years 2 weeks

Shakira's curves take the cake

3 years 34 weeks

those boots looks amazing with that dress shakira looks so much BETTER!

GlowingMoon 3 years 35 weeks

Shakira. What a feminine figure.

risqueredhead 3 years 35 weeks

Shakira, all the way. I love the boots.

tellmemorex2 3 years 35 weeks

Omg, I would be so embarrassed! But I think they both look great.

myystque 3 years 35 weeks

It certainly fits Shakira better but I voted for Pink because Shakira looks like a prostitute.

French Kiss 3 years 35 weeks

Sorry for pink, but this dress highlits Shakira.

mondo 3 years 35 weeks

It's all in the accessories and neither did justice to the dress.

billyart101 3 years 35 weeks

It's a really hot dress. I can see why they both picked it up! That's such a fun thing to have happened! I'm a fan of both girls.

doogirl 3 years 35 weeks

I love them both! They both put their own spin on the dress!

Briandiesel 3 years 35 weeks

I was honestly shocked that happened.

Lemerne 3 years 35 weeks

I don't think it's thanks to the boots that Shakira looks better, i think it's thanks to her hot curves :)

kastarte2 3 years 35 weeks

Shakira's curves make that dress more va va voom. It isn't really doing anything for Pink.

jenni5 3 years 35 weeks

I picked neither. I like it better on Shakira but hate the boots and I hate Pink's crazy hair.

rgrl 3 years 35 weeks

I think the dress looks better on PInk, with her tattoos and funky hair. The shoes not taking away from the super cool dress is a good thing too.

3 years 35 weeks

just because Shakira is prettier doesn't mean she wears the dress better... I'm going with Pink because I don't like the short dress with tall boots look.... The pumps look better!