Victoria Beckham and Elle Macpherson Both Wear Gray Victoria Beckham Collection Dress

Who Wore It Better? Victoria Beckham Gray Cashmere Dress

August 12, 2009

This is one battle I'm glad I'm not a part of. Victoria Beckham originally wore the gray cashmere dress from her Victoria Beckham Collection back in July in London. Of course, she didn't leave home without her sky-high Loubs and oversized sunnies. Super Elle Macpherson just showed up on the NYC set of The Beautiful Life wearing the same VB dress, only with lower, pointier pumps and equally oversized sunnies. Both ladies have amazing figures, but only one can take the cake. Who's it gonna be?

Source: WENN.com

32 Comments

AbbyHintz 3 years 40 weeks

DId anyone see that VB wore a very similar dress, but in red, on American Idol? http://www.dlisted.com/node/33408/images/spl114804_012.jpg

AbbyHintz 3 years 40 weeks

DId anyone see that VB wore a very similar dress, but in red, on American Idol? http://www.dlisted.com/node/33408/images/spl114804_012.jpg

lightgreen22 3 years 40 weeks

Elle

lightgreen22 3 years 40 weeks

Elle

NurseKimberly 3 years 40 weeks

ELLE

3 years 40 weeks

Elle looks like she strutting down a runway!

Charblit 3 years 40 weeks

Fab actually posted a link to Elle Macpherson saying that feminism is irrelevant and that men and women don't deserve equal rights, so I really can't justify voting for her, even if it's just about an outfit.

chloe bella 3 years 40 weeks

The whole thing is too tight on Elle - the skirt is puckering and her boobs are smashed. Also, I like how VB's platforms add an element of fun to what could be a very conservative look.

egar 3 years 40 weeks

VBshoes make a great difference

egar 3 years 40 weeks

VB shoes make a great difference

Michaelrcks 3 years 40 weeks

Victoria looks better!

Michaelrcks 3 years 40 weeks

Victoria looks better!

3 years 40 weeks

I agree 100% with Abby and quelle - the longer skirt is one of the best things about the outfit and looks great on her. She obviously designed it that way - it's very Edith Head / Hitchcock.

AbbyHintz 3 years 40 weeks

I love Victoria' below-the-knee skirt. Very classic look.

shannydoots 3 years 40 weeks

I agree with Violet Electric-- I'm not a fan of Elle's hair with this dress. But that's just me getting picky, I think they both look great in it.

quelle 3 years 40 weeks

the length of the skirt on posh doesn't bother me either. the silhouette of the dress feels very classic 40's/50's, so the length is perfect.i also feel that the bust area looks too tight on elle, and i think that 'string' is a headphones cord?? attached to an iphone?? does it go all the way up her dress?????? *so confused*

quelle 3 years 40 weeks

the length of the skirt on posh doesn't bother me either. the silhouette of the dress feels very classic 40's/50's, so the length is perfect. i also feel that the bust area looks too tight on elle, and i think that 'string' is a headphones cord?? attached to an iphone?? does it go all the way up her dress?????? *so confused*

Violet Electric 3 years 40 weeks

I prefer it on VB. The shoes she chose suit the dress better and i find Elle's hair distracting. I like that VB's hair is not interfering with the neckline and shoulders of the dress which is a part of what makes the dresses silhouette nice to me. The length situation doesnt bother me and what's going on with Elle and that string shes holding thats coming out from underneath the dress?!?!?