Victoria Beckham and Heidi Klum Wear the Same Victoria Beckham Collection Black Dress

Who Wore It Better? Victoria Beckham Collection LBD and YSL Pumps

March 3, 2009

Put two foxes in the same foxy LBD and YSL patent platforms and what do you get? Steamy competition. Hardbody homies Heidi Klum and Victoria Beckham both wore this skintight deep V Victoria Beckham dress and YSL's killer platform patent heels. Klum, unveiling the new Victoria's Secret Perfect One bra in Los Angeles let her arms breathe with nil accessories, while VB loaded on a fur shrug, motorcycle gloves, a Hermes bag, and black shades. What it boils down to is: minimal or maximum?

Source and Bauer-Griffin

39 Comments

Incubuslvr14 3 years 40 weeks

Heidi definitely looks better... too much for little Vic!

Poppy and the City 4 years 9 weeks

they both looked great. loved how posh accentuated the dress with gloves.both style worked for me :)

Poppy and the City 4 years 9 weeks

they both looked great. loved how posh accentuated the dress with gloves. both style worked for me :)

Claudiak 4 years 10 weeks

I think that VB looks great: stylish, glamorous and the gloves give it a funky edge, as somebody mentioned before Heidi's approach to the dress would be more suitable for the office. I also agree that it's not a fair comparison since i would like to see the coat and bag that Heidi got into the event in

designerel 4 years 10 weeks

I have to say Heidi because this dress can stand out on its own. It just may be a plain black dress, but the shoulders are very distinctive and you need to let that show.

Juicylemon 4 years 11 weeks

They both look fantastic. Though I'm more the minimal type like Heidi, Victoria's dress and accessories are well ^put together.

Glittersniffer 4 years 11 weeks

I'm up for both. They both make it look lovely.

chanelchain 4 years 11 weeks

I would usually say Victoria, but Heidi took this one. Her figure looks fantastiiiic in this.

tulleandtea 4 years 11 weeks

No way, Heidi doesn't even stand a chance. Victoria FTW! I love her. :)

LOVErickii 4 years 11 weeks

kudos to vb for the design but heidi went the right way letting the dres stand out without over accessorizing with a jacket

Mojo Jojo 4 years 11 weeks

They both look good, but I picked Heidi because I like the ring rather than gloves. I would like to know what kind of coat and bag Heidi chose for this dress because you know she has to have a bag, I feel like it is not a fair comparison. Vicki looks smashing tho, I would rock that look too, love the shrug.

ashantixoxo 4 years 11 weeks

They both look great! I don't think Victoria over did, common guys, from the picture looks like it was cold on that day, and she probably was going out...

halle44 4 years 11 weeks

i like Heidi...she looks amazing!!

aimeeb 4 years 11 weeks

Heidi

aimeeb 4 years 11 weeks

Heidi

any 4 years 11 weeks

both!!

any 4 years 11 weeks

both!!

fifthofapril 4 years 11 weeks

Heidi's take on it is too boring. Almost like something you would wear to the office. LOVE Victoria Beckham's take on it. The gloves add a perfect touch.

Michelann 4 years 11 weeks

They both look great. I think the real credit has to go to Victoria for designing such a perfect dress!

lizlee89 4 years 11 weeks

they both looks great, but Heidi looks insanely sexy and better. kind of a boring dress (like all of Victoria's "designs"), but Heidi makes it look amazing...

KadBunny 4 years 11 weeks

Aw how sad--someone rocked her own dress better :p haha. I do love how Victoria did it though; she always has a way with accessories (minus the fur, ugh :( ) but Heidi did muuch better.