Which America's Next Top Model Has the Best Seventeen Magazine Cover?

January 9, 2008

It surprised me when Saleisha Stowers won America's Next Top Model Season Nine, but like past winners CariDee English and Jaslene Gonzalez, she deserves to be on the cover of Seventeen Magazine. CariDee, who appeared on the February 2007 cover, is flirty and naughty. Jaslene, the July 2007 cover girl, is girly but intense. Saleisha, on the latest February 2008 magazine, is playful and sweet. Whose cover blew you away?

82 Comments

3 years 50 weeks

i really like jaselene's cover because i am half domincan she stood up for la familia

Isista 4 years 51 weeks

I picked CariDee. I loved her personality and her look throughout her season. I didn't want Jaslene to win though -- way too skinny, even if it is just her natural build. And I felt it was rigged, since she had tried out the season before. And Saleisha? Are you kidding? That was rigged from the start. I think that the rules do state that if you've worked with Tyra before, you aren't eligible for the show. If that's the case, then what the heck was Saleisha doing on the show? Even if I have my information wrong, which is possible, since I haven't been nearly as into ANTM the past couple seasons, she was NOT the best.

Isista 4 years 51 weeks

I picked CariDee. I loved her personality and her look throughout her season. I didn't want Jaslene to win though -- way too skinny, even if it is just her natural build. And I felt it was rigged, since she had tried out the season before.And Saleisha? Are you kidding? That was rigged from the start. I think that the rules do state that if you've worked with Tyra before, you aren't eligible for the show. If that's the case, then what the heck was Saleisha doing on the show? Even if I have my information wrong, which is possible, since I haven't been nearly as into ANTM the past couple seasons, she was NOT the best.

azucar_ame 5 years 15 weeks

I'll have to go woth CariDee! She looks naughty and nice ;-DJaslene is a little TOO Fierce for SeventeenSaleisha...I HATE that HAIR!! !azúcar! Ame

azucar_ame 5 years 15 weeks

I'll have to go woth CariDee! She looks naughty and nice ;-D Jaslene is a little TOO Fierce for Seventeen Saleisha...I HATE that HAIR!! !azúcar! Ame

pinkpixie_11 5 years 17 weeks

Jaslene!!!!

pinkpixie_11 5 years 17 weeks

Jaslene!!!!

verily 5 years 17 weeks

I picked CariDee. Jaslene was my favorite winner, but she looks so old on that cover. CariDee looks like she belongs on that cover. And Saleisha's is pretty good too, but not quite as stellar.

skatie07 5 years 17 weeks

I don't think Jaslene is pretty in the least bit.

vanilla19 5 years 18 weeks

Caridee has the best cover. It seriously seems like ANTM is staged, I don't really watch it anymore.

bizzybee 5 years 18 weeks

None of these covers are anything special. I think the models look too old for the magazine, as well.

OliveBlack 5 years 18 weeks

Caridee, she looks really pretty there, and appropriate to the magazine. Jaslene doesn't suit the look there at all, and the last one (haven't got to her cycle here yet) looks like she's wearing a bad wig.

Devine Destiny 5 years 18 weeks

Caridee is the greatest top model yet - she tops 'em all. She's mischevious n that laugh OMG - funny -.

sushiii 5 years 18 weeks

CariDee! After her, I stopped watch ANTM because it became kind of repeatitive and boring to me. She looks so gorgeous and her personality is so bubbly! I LOVE her. Jaslene looks pretty and Saleisha's so adorable with that hair on her. There was this other ANTM winner that I thought was super gorgeous but I forgot her name, haha.

mother fletcher 5 years 18 weeks

Um, they all look horrible. Sorry but there's nothing cute or original about any of them. Plus, every time I see Jaslene all I hear is her horrible, grating voice.

Nitachequita 5 years 18 weeks

CariDee. Jaslene looks like a tranny, and while Saleisha is pretty, she's not model-pretty.

TFS 5 years 18 weeks

errrrrr what were they thinking with that Jaslene girl?! she looks like a whore you see in some back alley in new york rofl.

gigill 5 years 18 weeks

I think the CarrieDee's is the most "Seventeen" out of the three. Is it just me or does Jaslene photograph a little "old" in this photo considering the demographic?