Who Do You Think Should Have Won Project Runway?

October 18, 2006

The season has come to a close, and it's offical: Designer Jeffrey Sebelia is the winner of Project Runway Season 3! (Tune in later today for my wrap-up of the finale.) But did he deserve to win?

Fab Poll

24 Comments

LaylaCams 6 years

I wanted Uli to win also. But didn't we know along time ago that he won?

yiddidea 6 years

I think Jeffrey should have won. Uli had nice peices, but her collection was not cohesive. The flowy dressed did not go with her urban, silvery sleek peices at all. I loved the stuff she made, but as a collection it didn't work. Jeffrey had a definite point of view. As for the cheating allegation, I do not believe it. He does this for a living, so why shouldn't we expect him to be able to pull off 12 perfectly sewn garments in 2 months? He had a clear vision, so he had to spend less time on the design and had more time to perfect the construction. As for the budget issue, he took out the wigs. After doing that he was under budget. Anybody remember Kera Saun's shoes on the first season. That was cheating!

hotstuff 6 years

Fashion I totally agree about the receipts! That was so stupid! Like cheaters get receipts after getting someone else to make their stuff. LOL

PinkSparkleGrl 6 years

I am totally tossed between Uli and Laura, they are the best of both the casual and elegant fashions. They were hard set in their ideas and produced excellent outfits during the entire season. Jeffery only produced a few that were wearable, and in most cases he received alot of criticism from the judges. I feel that in a way he cheated because they are not his designs, I see a piece from every prominent designer of PR; whats up with the Uli dress in his collection?! I agree that Micheal has to grow out of the hot pants faze, but he did have some excellent designs himself; just some trouble on the "create your own outfit to describe yourself" challenge. All and all I am very disappointed in the decision because the winner should score should be based on the average of all challenges weighted by the finale.

fashionistanyc 6 years

I totally agree, hotstuff!

hotstuff 6 years

He definitely seemed to cheat! How did he not have 1 button to sew? And the quality of his work was all of a sudden perfect. Whatever Jeffrey :)! He also broke so many rules yet they still let him win?

fashionistanyc 6 years

No idea how they picked Jeffrey over Uli. Her collection was better and at the very least, Jeffrey broke the rules by going over budget. Did anyone else have a problem with the way they resolved that issue? I never heard them explain how exactly they were able to tell the stuff was his, other than receipts. I mean it's not like he'd give them receipts of stuff other people made for him against the rules, right? So how could they tell by that? I'm not saying he cheated but I just didn't think they really explained it well. I'm disappointed. Still love the show, though.

hotstuff 6 years

I love Michael as a person overall and his fashion. His collection at the end could have been a lot better. They all had some fabulous pieces. I would have picked Uli to win. She's the only one who did step out of her box a little. Who can seriously wear any of Jeffreys stuff? Maybe one or two pieces thats about it.

npogrl 6 years

I was excited that Jeffrey won. I thought his collection was the best because it was innovative and showed more diversity than the others. Uli and Laura where one noters for their designs, even though both ladies could put them together flawlessly, and Michael, who I thought would win, had a line that was really just a mess. I don't know what happened to him, but I was heartbroken when I saw his creations. Jeffrey really surprised me, and except for a couple of his babydolls which I thought were a little lame, I thought his outfits were great.

SaRaH 22 6 years

if we were voting for season overall michael should have one..but just by the run way show i was rooting for Jeffrey or Uli(i want one of every one of her long flowy dresses) ~*~Life was Simpler back then~*~

peepshow 6 years

Michael's stuff looked rushed. I liked Lauras, and I can see her designing for a dept. store. I liked Uli's stuff the best, and she's going to go far. Nina said that she already has a lead! YEAH! Jeffrey's stuff was trendy, and I can't imagine him going outside of the whole rocker/punk thing. And that's going to go out of sytle come spring... HELLO 80s!

BlondeSugar 6 years

I loved Michael's stuff, but didn't really like his final collection. Uli was great too

cubadog 6 years

I LOVED Jeffrey's colelction. He has vision and right now the fashion industry needs a little shakin' up. Uli is a great dress maker but come on that is all she made BORING. I agree with you Lil if Laura had won I would have to stop watching! She needs to shut-up and go home to her 6 kids and play with turtle poop!

lil_bit_edgy 6 years

i'm happy jeffrey won. i would have been just as happy if michael won but his street safari was not cute...gold pockets...wtf? uli and laura just pulled the same things from waht they did through the whole entire season. i think uli tied in her collection with the horn but other than that it wasn't that cohesive. jeffrey's collection made me think of marc jacobs, vivienne westwood, john galliano, etc. he definitely had a good point of view with a cohesive collection that flowed but didn't repeat too much. (i.e. michael's tie-front necklines, uli's deep cuts in the front, laura's everything) if laura had won i would have stopped watching the show all together!

Neural 6 years

I actually haven't seen the finale yet (bf has tivoed it for me, though) but I was rooting for Laura for the last few weeks cuz I find her collection to be the most wearable and classic.

skinny fat 6 years

I loved Jeffrey's collection and hated Laura for being such a bitch, plus she makes the same dress over and over. Uli's collection was also nice but she bores me a bit. I was completely surprised at how horrible and trashy Michael's was.

BeckyG 6 years

I can't cast a vote because I was really disappointed in all their collections. Seriously, every time they were told to "WOW us," they fell through. And the judging session left much to be desired - c'mon Michael Kors! I need some more comments about big-steppin briefs!!

creamytofu 6 years

i did like jeffrey's collection the most. Uli's collection was also good. Laura is the same, how many variations of the black dress and a v-neck do we need. i was hoping tat micheal would win. His collection was very disappointing. Overall Uli should have won.

txgirlie 6 years

I was also disappointed by Michael. However, Uli really pulled through, and I agree that she got shafted. I thought her collection was great.

AtlantaNoleGirl 6 years

I liked Uli's stuff too, but I think Jefferey has done a solid job all the way through and I liked his collection. I even liked Laura's final showing. And though I've liked Michael throughout the season, I hated his final collection!

siren6 6 years

Uli was ROBBED. Robbed!

JK Boogie 6 years

But to be honest I am not sure I would take fashion advice from someone who looks like this guy

JK Boogie 6 years

:( we dont have it in the UK

celeb_addicted04 6 years

Fab!!....you should have said SPOILER..cuz in Canada there are still 7 contestants left..but its ok..so Jeffrey won?...i thought he was mean but i wanted Uli to win, she is such a good designer

Link Love

24 Comments