Who Wore It Better? Alexander McQueen Asymmetrical Drape Dress

January 9, 2008

Yesterday I showed you how to get Lucy's hot-pink Alexander McQueen Look For Less, and today she's up for a style battle. The dress she wore for her Late Show appearance earlier this week is one and the same as the black McQueen dress Sienna Miller wore for the premiere of her film Interview back in October. Lucy went more bold with brighter color and leather gloves, while Sienna played it sleek and chic with a contrasting clutch and chandelier earrings. Who wins?!

Source and Source

50 Comments

lizlee89 5 years 13 weeks

I love bright colors, but I HATEEEEE that pink of Lucy's dress...they both look great in the dress and accesorized it well, but Sienna's color is better and I love her accesories especially the clutch...

angelcandy 5 years 17 weeks

The dress looks great but not feeling the pink color but the belt really finishes it off.

LettyRN 5 years 18 weeks

Lucy definitely looks better.

LettyRN 5 years 18 weeks

Lucy definitely looks better.

Calimie 5 years 19 weeks

I prefer Lucy because of the belt. It finishes the dress. I don't really like the dress, the colour or her gloves but the touch of the belt looks really good. Sienna's too shapless and classic.

lizzylu49 5 years 19 weeks

Sienna. Strictly because the black gloves are hideous.

designerel 5 years 19 weeks

I'm not a fan of the dress, but I think Lucy went the right route with the belt. Sienna's ankles look like they might snap!

fleetstreet 5 years 19 weeks

the belt pulls it together... on sienna it looks a tad shapeless

wren 5 years 19 weeks

I prefer it with a belt, but I cannot stand the bright pink. And Sienna's shoes are soooo cute.

bransugar79 5 years 19 weeks

I like Lucy's look better because the dress looks better belted and I think the choice of pick over black is adventurous. I wish she would have gone without the gloves because it just looks a little too costumey to me but other than that I think she looks 100% better in it

freegracefrom 5 years 19 weeks

I really hate that look for Lucy. But the more I look at it, maybe it'd be more tolerable without the gloves. As for Sienna - something like Lucy's belt to break up the block of black and point out where her waist is? I guess I'm just not a fan of this dress, period.

gruaig_rua 5 years 19 weeks

Lucy, although I wish she would lose the gloves.

MrsJigglesworth 5 years 19 weeks

Lucy!

MrsJigglesworth 5 years 19 weeks

Lucy!

tiabia 5 years 19 weeks

Lucy Lui!!!

tiabia 5 years 19 weeks

Lucy Lui!!!

mediafreak 5 years 19 weeks

Both of them look great but I voted Lucy because Sienna's hair looks too casual for the dress.

leeluvfashion 5 years 19 weeks

I love Sienna's. Lucy's is too over-the-top for me.

any 5 years 19 weeks

i like both

any 5 years 19 weeks

i like both

MissCreole 5 years 19 weeks

Love Sienna's look even though I enjoy Lucy's color~

kamu76 5 years 19 weeks

Like both, but Lucy wins (maybe without the gloves though). Love Lucy's belt, and Sienna's would look better with shoes like Lucy's.

ccsugar 5 years 19 weeks

Oh wow. I totally thought that was MK Olsen til I read the description!! Anyway, I think Lucy looks better, I like that she belted it but I hate those gloves.