Who Wore It Better? Rails Indya Black Hoodie

December 21, 2007

When Lindsay Lohan left rehab, she was sporting a Rails Indya black hoodie. A couple days ago ex-reality star Kristin Cavallari went shopping in the same jacket. Side note: John Mayer's girlfriend Minka Kelly has the off-white one. Both LL and Kristin are blonde, thin, and trendy . . . . but who do you think wore it better?

Flynet

32 Comments

mikaela star 3 years 46 weeks

kristin

sugajen 5 years 21 weeks

The jacket is rather dull so I give it up to Lohan for keeping it interesting with bold stripes. Kristen I wouldn't look twice at she looks blah

amber_castaldo 5 years 21 weeks

Kristen I really do like the simplicity of the outfit!

Glittersniffer 5 years 21 weeks

I think they both pull it off well, but the real issue I'm fighting is that I want this sweater so badly! (NOT calling it a hoodie, I made a promise when I started college that hoodies were for sick days only). It's like peacoat lite. But 140 bucks? Right steep for me at the moment, the holidays have tapped me out!

Hanahin 5 years 21 weeks

Kristin — her look is simpler, and I like it better buttoned.

ESTONE 5 years 21 weeks

I really don't like either of them but Kristen looks much cuter. Ew, it pained me to say that.

pink_magnetism 5 years 21 weeks

I voted Kristin, but because her hair looks better than Lindsay's.

do it 5 years 21 weeks

Kristin ;)

msshellokitty 5 years 21 weeks

kristin

MariaIsTipsy 5 years 21 weeks

KRISTIN* Ahhh so sorry agin teamsugar but its only my second time. Sorry. Much Luv!

MariaIsTipsy 5 years 21 weeks

KRISTEN. Love the jacket buttoned up and it paired with simple, jeans and shoes.

bailaoragaditana 5 years 21 weeks

Kristin. Although the open-toed shoes are a bit strange. But she still looks more put-together than Lindsey, and ditto royalblue - I just don't like Lindsey. Well, not since "The Parent Trap," anyway.

TASTEthiss 5 years 21 weeks

lindsay automatically got my vote because kristen has on a hoodie with open toe shoes. i dont consider that polished.. more like confused.

eloise81 5 years 21 weeks

Kristin looks fab!

bvfashion 5 years 21 weeks

I think Lindsay wears it better, because I think I'm the only one thats noticed so far, but Kristin is wearing open toed shoes with a hoodie and jeans. What is that?? Her shoes are totally out of whack with the rest of the outfit. At least Lindsay's whole look works together.