i gotta go with leighton on this one.. i commend her for NOT making a boring choice.

Tizz then Leighton. wow she def step it up a nodge after the disastrous dress from MET

Sienna and then my second place vote goes to Leighton.

Ashley then Leighton. I kinda wish Leighton wore shoes more like Ashley's... those booties make her legs look so short.

Ashley looks great

I voted Kristen but Sienna is a super close second!

Both are super cute and fun!

ashley then leighton. i think if leighton had on different shoes i would have loved her look more.

The only one I like is Whitney's.

Leighton then Kristen...both look great

i would have liked to see leighton in different shoes.

I'm clearly the only one that thinks Ashley looks like a second-rate J-Lo here. Hmm. I like Leighton's dress.

I think Kristen Stewart belongs to this list.

Honestly, I didn't really like any of last night's looks, but out of these, I'm going with Ashely or Whitney.

And Chicandcool, the more I look at her outfit, I kind of like Kristen Stewart's outfit last night...it reminds me of Spiderman a bit, but I do like how she wore her Chucks with it.

None of them! I thought that Vanessa Hudgens looked the best in the flowing orange dress.

Went with Sienna... really love that colour on her and the style is very cool!

Again Leighton look's great and thought a very brave, cool choice but the boot's are to heavy with it.

Sienna. I love the pop of green.

Leighton should have worn Ashley's shoes.

Leighton for sure. She's risky and she pulls it off well.

Ashley looks really orange.

leighton= scary

ICK! Why is Sienna a choice?! I agree with Leila, Vanessa Hudgens looked great! Of those choices above though, I pick Leighton without a doubt.

Astonishingly bad fashion night at the MTV awards. REALLY bad.

Sienna, although this picture doesn't do it justice. The reason I thought she was the best was due to the back of the dress...

I love Kristen Bell's dress - I would LOVE to own a dress like that.

I thought Leighton's dress was hot, but Ashley won hands down her look was much more wearable and I'm sure you can find something similar at a cheaper pricepoint!

I frikkin' love Leighton's talent and allowance to take fashion risks. girl's got guts and it pays off (most of the time

I feel like Ashley Tisdale's is too trendy, as in a trying to hard way. The accesories and makeup (that fake tan) are overpowering. Leighton had a bold dress but didn't overwhelm me.

Love Leighton, but... the back of the dress is largely sheer. Can't get behind that. (haha, get it? behind?)

Sienna.

Leighton.

i think leighton and ashley both look great exept for leighton shoes

what an awful night....bad bad outfits I'm so disappointed...

Whitney was closest to my own style so I picked her.

Leighton and then Whitney. I would love to wear those dresses.

Sienna looks great! Love her style!

I could have loaned leighton the perfect shoes for that dress!! why did she not call me?

Am I the only one that was extremely disappointed with the MTVMA fashions?
There wasn't ONE that I would even want to wear...

I'm SOOOOO over gladiator/chunky sandals.

i think that vanessa hudgens is best dressed that the others girls

Not a fan of any of these

ASHLEY TISDALE looked SO HOT
i vote Ashley

Sienna, hands down.

Ashley wins YES
i Luv the Tiz

Ashley was the fashion queen of the red carpet that night! I've never seen her looking so fierce/hot/sexy/gorgeous like at the MTV Movie Awards!
I seriously loved everything she's wearing! She looked awesome!
ASHLEY ALL THE WAYYYY

ashley tisdale looks so beautful that night.
she is the best!
love her

ASHLEY TISDALE, IS THE BEST!! =)

ASHLEY \o then Kristen s2

I was gonna go with Sienna's beautiful mini, but Leighton won me over with edgyness. It was afterall MTV, so I find Leighton's bold choice more appealing overall.

OMG!!!!!!!!...=)
i love ashley tisdale!!.
she´s sooo hot!!
she won!!...yayy..obviusly she won because she is the best!!!
i love leighton meester too...but the dress was horrible!!!.........

ashley the best!!!!....
so cute!
xoxo
sol

i love ashley tisdale!!
the best forever!!!=)

increible!...me encanta ashley y odio a vanessa!!!!
=)