• Home
  • Login/Register
  • Start A Group!
  • Join Now
fabsugar Home
// Explore Our Community
  • Celebrity
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Sex & Culture
  • Entertainment
  • Home Decor
  • Health
  • Mom & Kids
  • Food
  • Money
  • Tech
  • Pets
  • TV
  • Etc
  • 2009 fall award season
  • Latest
  • Community
  • Features
    Fab Finds Look of the Day Celeb Style Love it or Hate it Fab Polls Trend Alert Look Book Love Fashion Editorials Sneak Peeks Fashion Quizzes Industry News Giveaways Sites We Love
  • Celebrities
    Diane Kruger Kate Moss Cameron Diaz Olivia Palermo Ashley Olsen Victoria Beckham Rachel Bilson Reese Witherspoon Gwyneth Paltrow Rihanna Kate Bosworth» All Celebrities
  • Brands
    Zara Stella McCartney Urban Outfitters Marc Jacobs H&M Gucci Alexander McQueen Alexander Wang Forever 21 Chanel
  • Games
    Who's More Fab? Couture or Ready-To-Wear? Celebrity Faceoff Movie Faceoff TV Show Faceoff Which Pet is Cuter? Memory Slots Celebrity Puzzle Gift Shop Sponsored Games Sparkle Catcher Flavor Burst Fortune Teller
  • RSS
  • MyYahoo
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Follow FabSugar:
  • AU•
  • UK•
  • US•
    • 2009 Primetime Emmy Awards
    • 2009 MTV VMAs
    • Fashion Polls
    • Beauty Polls
    • Celebrity Galleries

    Love This Email Print Facebook Stumble It!
    Related: Red Carpet, Pink, Shakira, Who Wore It Better, Celebrity, 2009 MTV VMAs, 2009 MTV VMAs Poll
    12345…Next ›Last Page »
    1 of 34
    MTV Video Music Awards: Who Wore It Better?
    Sep 13 2009 - 6:00pm Red carpet fashion faux pas alert. Pink and Shakira just arrived on the MTV VMA red carpet in the same Balmain dress! Looks like they were able to laugh it off, however.
    Read More ›
     
    Source: WireImage
     

    Like this? Be the first! Please login or register to like this

    38 Comments Post a Comment

    emalove's picture
     
    emalove [+]

    Shakira!

    1
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:01pm Report Comment
    genesisrocks's picture
     
    genesisrocks [+]

    Drama on the red carpet! Shakira wins

    2
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:01pm Report Comment
    zoet's picture
     
    zoet [+]

    Oh Snap!! Haha but Shakira's looks better the boots pull the outfit together.

    3
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:03pm Report Comment
    pss's picture
     
    pss [+]

    it looks better on shakira, but that boots...anyone cant win anything with those...so Pink.

    4
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:05pm Report Comment
    rafaela losardo's picture
     
    rafaela losardo [+]

    shakira!

    5
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:07pm Report Comment
    nikkeeb's picture
     
    nikkeeb [+]

    don't they have people to prevent this?

    6
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:20pm Report Comment
    poizenisxkandee's picture
     
    poizenisxkandee [+]

    thigh high boots really vamp that dress up. shakira!

    7
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:21pm Report Comment
    moime's picture
     
    moime

    it fits shakira wayyyy BETTER.
    on pink it looks like a boy in a dress...

    8
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:24pm Report Comment
    simplyfab87's picture
     
    simplyfab87 [+]

    Shakira!

    9
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:24pm Report Comment
    jhilly123's picture
     
    jhilly123 [+]

    They both look great, but Shakira just looks better in the dress... her curves fit the dress/makes it look better.

    10
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:30pm Report Comment
    Claudia Lopez's picture
     
    Claudia Lopez [+]

    SHAKIRA! I have to support here, Im colombian too Laughing out loud

    11
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 6:52pm Report Comment
    Erica Kane's picture
     
    Erica Kane [+]

    I'm going for Shakira her boots are doing it for me!

    12
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 7:35pm Report Comment
    totygoliguez's picture
     
    totygoliguez [+]

    Shakira, shakira.

    13
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 7:44pm Report Comment
    ksrli's picture
     
    ksrli [+]

    I think it looks good on both of them. Shakira's curves just fit the dress better.

    14
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 7:49pm Report Comment
    lmf8899's picture
     
    lmf8899 [+]

    This dress was born for Pink. Shakira's trying to hard with those boots. Easy up on the "badass" girl!

    15
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 7:58pm Report Comment
    shelbyrist's picture
     
    shelbyrist [+]

    Oh somebody at Balmain is so getting fired over this little mishap.

    16
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 8:24pm Report Comment
    Glittersniffer's picture
     
    Glittersniffer [+]

    Pink gets my vote, because she WINS.

    17
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 8:40pm Report Comment
    sidra5397's picture
     
    sidra5397 [+]

    I love them both! They wore the dress in different styles and both really rocked it. I really don't feel that one wore it better than the other.

    18
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 9:04pm Report Comment
    sidra5397's picture
     
    sidra5397 [+]

    Ha! They're also posing in the same location. The people in the crowd can be seen in both images.

    19
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 9:06pm Report Comment
    KibzeeLovee's picture
     
    KibzeeLovee [+]

    they both do look great. but i'm lovin shakira shakira's boots

    20
    Sun, 09/13/2009 - 11:43pm Report Comment
    qtpie's picture
     
    qtpie [+]

    Shakira, the dress looks better hugging her curves

    21
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 12:35am Report Comment
    zeze's picture
     
    zeze [+]

    Shakira, Pink is built like a man, even her boob in that see-though leotard look like a man's pec...doesn't go with a dress made for curves.

    22
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 1:18am Report Comment
    bluestar's picture
     
    bluestar [+]

    Pink!

    23
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 4:15am Report Comment
    Anonymous's picture
     
    Anonymous

    just because Shakira is prettier doesn't mean she wears the dress better... I'm going with Pink because I don't like the short dress with tall boots look.... The pumps look better!

    24
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 5:16am Report Comment
    romaniagrl's picture
     
    romaniagrl [+]

    I think the dress looks better on PInk, with her tattoos and funky hair. The shoes not taking away from the super cool dress is a good thing too.

    25
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 5:28am Report Comment
    jennibean5's picture
     
    jennibean5 [+]

    I picked neither. I like it better on Shakira but hate the boots and I hate Pink's crazy hair.

    26
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 6:40am Report Comment
    kastarte2's picture
     
    kastarte2 [+]

    Shakira's curves make that dress more va va voom. It isn't really doing anything for Pink.

    27
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 6:52am Report Comment
    Meriem's picture
     
    Meriem [+]

    I don't think it's thanks to the boots that Shakira looks better, i think it's thanks to her hot curves Smiling

    28
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 7:37am Report Comment
    Briandiesel's picture
     
    Briandiesel [+]

    I was honestly shocked that happened.

    29
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 8:09am Report Comment
    doogirl's picture
     
    doogirl [+]

    I love them both! They both put their own spin on the dress!

    30
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 8:46am Report Comment
    billyart101's picture
     
    billyart101 [+]

    It's a really hot dress. I can see why they both picked it up! That's such a fun thing to have happened! I'm a fan of both girls.

    31
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 11:30am Report Comment
    mondo's picture
     
    mondo [+]

    It's all in the accessories and neither did justice to the dress.

    32
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 11:32am Report Comment
    French Kiss's picture
     
    French Kiss [+]

    Sorry for pink, but this dress highlits Shakira.

    33
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 11:45am Report Comment
    myystque's picture
     
    myystque [+]

    It certainly fits Shakira better but I voted for Pink because Shakira looks like a prostitute.

    34
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 11:55am Report Comment
    tellmemorex2's picture
     
    tellmemorex2 [+]

    Omg, I would be so embarrassed! But I think they both look great.

    35
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 3:27pm Report Comment
    risqueredhead's picture
     
    risqueredhead [+]

    Shakira, all the way. I love the boots.

    36
    Mon, 09/14/2009 - 3:50pm Report Comment
    GlowingMoon's picture
     
    GlowingMoon [+]

    Shakira. What a feminine figure.

    37
    Wed, 09/16/2009 - 4:44pm Report Comment
    Anonymous's picture
     
    Anonymous

    those boots looks amazing with that dress shakira looks so much BETTER!

    38
    Sun, 09/20/2009 - 4:58am Report Comment

    Post New Comment

    Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.

    If you are already a member, or would like to receive email alerts as new comments are made, please login or register. Or connect with your Facebook account: .
    The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


    More on FabSugar

    Kristen Stewart Style, Post-Twilight, Present-New Moon
    Fab Gift Guide: 15 Under $50 For Your BFF
    She's So Unusual: Katy Perry's Outrageous Performance Outfits
    This Week's Fab Faves
    It's Hot in Here! 2010 Pirelli Calendar Photo Shoot
    Looks of the Week!

    Holiday

    yumsugar The Basics: Pear Crisp
    casasugar DIY: CB2 Ornament Wreath
    yumsugar Burning Question: What's the Difference Between Stuffing and Dressing?
    bellasugar Are You Ready For Holiday Beauty?
    fitsugar Rosemary Pear Sparkler
    savvysugar 8 Steps to Financially Prepare For the Holidays
    ShopStyle Headlines
    Top Brands
    1.  Marc by Marc Jacobs
    2. 7 For All Mankind
    3.  Alice + Olivia
    4. Christian Louboutin
    5. Hive Modern
    6. Prada
    7. Betsey Johnson
    8. Prada
    9.  Bloch
    10. Annie
    11. Calvin Klein
    12. Old Navy
    13. Hive Modern
    14. Sur La Table
    15. N.V. Perricone
    Top Searches
    1. louboutin heels
    2. plaid jacket
    3. bomber jackets
    4. halter
    5. cream dresses
    6. black tunic
    7. orange tunic
    8. blow dryers
    9. cole haan nike air
    10. black capri
    11. striped bikini
    12. flat sandal
    13. mcqueen sale
    14. skirt
    15. leather hoodie
    Insanely Addictive.
    1. Fierce Shopper
    2. Guess Who?
    3. Biker Boy
    4. Jessica Shops Till She Drops For Holiday Treats
    5. Date Night
    6. Taylor Strips Down, Eclipse Has a Release Date, a Peek at Tonight's Glee and Our Holiday Weekend Movie Reviews!
    7. Stocking Up
    8. Kate and Ryder Are on Cloud Nine After the Circus
    9. Vampy
    10. Katie Has Something to Talk About During New Moon
    11. RSS Feed
    Have. Want. Need.
    1. Happy Thanksgiving!
    2. Sneak Peek! Lerario Beatriz, Spring '10
    3. The Look For Less: Phillip Lim Recycled Zipper Dress
    4. Which Rihanna Rated R Getup Is Most Fab?
    5. Victoria Beckham Creates Sleeker, Chicer Denim For Spring
    6. Play Our Fabulous American Music Awards Faceoff!
    7. Topshop Lets You Borrow from Kate, Freida, Scarlett, and More!
    8. Celeb Style: Selita Ebanks
    9. Fab Finger Discount: Seneca Rising Levi Minidress
    10. Look of the Day: Fall Foliage
    11. RSS Feed
    You're beautiful.
    1. The Hills Beauty Quiz: Episode Nine, "Mr. Right Now"
    2. Have You Ever Made Your Own Makeup?
    3. Atomic: The Prettiest Atomizers Out There
    4. 4 Lip Balm Ingredients to Avoid
    5. Love It or Hate It? Topshop's Sequined Top Hat Clip
    6. Reader Review of the Day: Cetaphil Daily Facial Moisturizer
    7. John Frieda's Quick Tip on Creating Instant Volume
    8. Festive Gifts For Your Holiday Hostess
    9. Is "Ginger-ism" Growing in the United States?
    10. Patrick Dempsey Talks to Us About His Latest Scent
    11. RSS Feed
    Smart. Sexy. Fun.
    1. Happy Thanksgiving!
    2. What Do You Know About Thanksgiving?
    3. Do Tell: What Thanksgiving Drama Are You Dreading?
    4. Say What? First Lady Carla Bruni to Star in Woody Allen Film
    5. Oh Snap! Sasha Considers Going Vegetarian
    6. Together or Not? TV Couples in Real Life
    7. A Tax on Cosmetic Surgery — Love It or Leave It?
    8. Speed Read! Roman Polanski's Bail Offer Approved
    9. Hump Day: What to Do When He's Not Well Endowed
    10. Dinner Is Over! And No Thanksgiving
    11. RSS Feed
    Entertainment hourly.
    1. What to TiVo: Thursday
    2. Buzz Gift Guide: The Guy's Guy
    3. Taylor Strips Down, Eclipse Has a Release Date, a Peek at Tonight's Glee and Our Holiday Weekend Movie Reviews!
    4. Play Our Brand New Holiday Movie Faceoff and Win a Prize!
    5. Link Time! First Look at Shrek Ever After
    6. Me and Orson Welles: A Likeable Film For Theater-Lovers
    7. Do You Still Watch Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade?
    8. Buzz In: What Shows Will You Catch Up on During the Hiatus?
    9. The Road: A Bleak Journey That Will Haunt You
    10. What to TiVo: Wednesday
    11. RSS Feed
    Home sweet home.
    1. Share Your Thanksgiving Photos With Our Community!
    2. Link Time!
    3. Leslie Bamburg's Go-To Holiday Gift Ideas
    4. How-To: Remove Strippable Wallpaper
    5. Casa Quickie: Cable Clutter Fix
    6. Are You Hosting This Thanksgiving?
    7. Jonathan Adler Brings the Gossip Bench Back!
    8. Do You Light a Fire at Thanksgiving?
    9. Rihanna Refuses to Pick Robert or Taylor, New Moon on Late Night, and Farewell to Jon and Kate Plus 8
    10. Dress Up to Win
    11. RSS Feed
    Happy healthy you.
    1. Instead of Feeling Guilty For Indulging, Get Back on Track
    2. If You're Drinking This Holiday Season, Go Green
    3. Speak Up: How Do You Feel About Indulging on Thanksgiving?
    4. Stretch It: Shoulder and Neck Stretching Backbend
    5. Healthy Thanksgiving Sides and Desserts
    6. You Asked: Could Wine Give Me a Headache?
    7. Food For Thought: T-Day Digestion
    8. Do You Ask People Not to Smoke Around You?
    9. Junk Food May Be as Addictive as Heroin
    10. Food Review: Celebration Roast
    11. RSS Feed
    Mommy's little helper
    1. Download Our Free Games Before Your Thanksgiving Travel!
    2. Sugarbabies: One Happy Turkey
    3. Lil Links: Daddy Ben Is on Pickup Duty
    4. Holiday Trendtotting: Classic Little Red Dresses
    5. What Do You Know About Ear Tubes?
    6. Will the Children Give Thanks at a Kiddie Table?
    7. Did You Have to Talk Your Man Into Fatherhood?
    8. Rihanna Refuses to Pick Robert or Taylor, New Moon on Late Night, and Farewell to Jon and Kate Plus 8
    9. Sugarbabies: For the Love of Broccoli
    10. Dress Up to Win
    11. RSS Feed
    To die for.
    1. Are You on Top of Your Turkey Trivia?
    2. Happy Hour: BarbaRoja Barrel-Aged Red Ale
    3. Don't Forget to Share Your Thanksgiving Meal With Us!
    4. YumTV: A Killer App to Kick Off Your Thanksgiving Meal
    5. The Procrastinator's Perfect Answer to Thanksgiving Turkey
    6. Spatchcocking
    7. Come Party With Me: Last Minute Thanksgiving — Dessert
    8. Food Section Sampler — Nov. 25, 2009
    9. Fast & Easy Dinner: Tomato Bisque With Mozzarella Crostini
    10. Have You Started Cooking For Thanksgiving Yet?
    11. RSS Feed
    Geek is chic
    1. Ernarae's Blinged-Out Homemade iPhone Case
    2. Website of the Day: Honk
    3. GeekSugar's Gift Guide For Newlyweds
    4. Daily Tech: Microsoft Opens a Lounge in Saks Fifth Avenue NY
    5. The Hills Tech Quiz: Episode 9, "Mr. Right Now"
    6. How Do You Prefer to Holiday Shop?
    7. Old-Fashioned Cases For High-Tech Gadgets
    8. I'm Gearing Up For Hot Black Friday Deals From Target
    9. The City Tech Quiz: Episode 9, "If You Want Something Done Right"
    10. Get Free MP3s From Amazon — No Strings Attached
    11. RSS Feed
    It makes sense.
    1. Follow These Tips For an Easy, Breezy Thanksgiving Trip
    2. How Long Are You Willing to Wait in a Black Friday Line?
    3. Is Your Job Busier During the Holidays?
    4. Play Our Which Career Is Cooler? Game to Win Money!
    5. Simple Thanksgiving Shopping Tips That Will Help You Save
    6. Rihanna Refuses to Pick Robert or Taylor, New Moon on Late Night, and Farewell to Jon and Kate Plus 8
    7. Productivity Advice From White House Deputy Chief of Staff
    8. Dress Up to Win
    9. What Are Your Thanksgiving Plans?
    10. Savvy Links: Could You Go a Year Without Buying Clothes?
    11. RSS Feed
    Girl's best friend.
    1. Quiz: Pardon Me, Little Turkey, It's 2009!
    2. The Scoop: Pet Airways Launches Thanksgiving Day "Flight to Freedom" For Adoptable Pets
    3. Pancreatitis Is a Hidden Danger of Thanksgiving Dinner
    4. Pet Pic of the Day: Nikos Is Mighty Fine
    5. 6 T'giving Tips For Turkey Day
    6. Rihanna Refuses to Pick Robert or Taylor, New Moon on Late Night, and Farewell to Jon and Kate Plus 8
    7. Dress Up to Win
    8. Sara Gets a Gentle Giraffe-y Nudge
    9. Martha's Pups Play Leafy Hide-and-Seek: In the LINK of an Eye!
    10. Is a DIY Tape Measure Cat Toy Brilliant or Baffling?
    11. RSS Feed
    Insanely addictive.
    1. Soul Mates Dev and Freida Say Hello to the Animals
    2. Kate Moss Kicks Back With Take That At Singstar Shindig!
    3. New Moon Fan Amy Winehouse Has Christmas Wrapped
    4. Cerys Welcomes Her New Baby Boy Eight Weeks Early!
    5. What To Sky+: Thursday
    6. Guess Who?
    7. Win Tickets to Watch The Saturdays Perform Live In London!
    8. Zac Efron Talks Bungee Jumping on Letterman
    9. Do You Want to See John & Edward in the Jungle?
    10. Link Time!
    11. RSS Feed
    Have, want, need.
    1. Fab Flash: Sales of Corsets Increase
    2. Victoria Beckham Relaunches Denim Line
    3. Do You Have a Special Bag for your Laptop?
    4. Ungaro CEO Defends Lindsay
    5. Fab Gift Guide: Dedicated Follower of Fashion
    6. Love it or Hate it: Natalie Portman at the NYC Ballet
    7. Which Pink Lipstick Do You Like Most on Ashley Greene?
    8. Is Emma Watson Working with YSL?
    9. BellaSugar's Gift Guide: The Sports Stud
    10. On Our Radar: Colette Pop Up Store
    11. RSS Feed
    Looks of the stars
    1. Celeb Style: Mischa Barton
    2. Celeb Style: Nicky Hilton
    3. Celeb Style: Rihanna
    4. Celeb Style: Claudia Schiffer
    5. Cougar Town Style: Laurie Keller
    6. Cougar Town Style: Jules Cobb
    7. Celeb Style: Olivia Palermo
    8. Celeb Style: Rose Byrne
    9. Celeb Style: Ashley Tisdale
    10. Celeb Style: Rihanna
    Sugar Inc.
    • Advertise with Us
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Policy
    • ©Copyright 1976-2009 / Sweet! FabSugar is proudly OnSugar.